There’s been some speculation that Cowboys coach Mike McCarthy’s job status could be tied to his team’s playoff performance. However, barring some unexpected change, it’s sounding like McCarthy will be safe regardless of the postseason. As ESPN’s Dan Graziano passes along, “minds would likely have to be changed” if the Cowboys fire McCarthy following a disappointing playoff showing.
Graziano notes that ownership has been impressed by McCarthy’s ability to right the ship in Dallas, especially from an offensive perspective. He’s also kept his squad “even-keeled all season,” and ESPN’s Jeremy Fowler adds that the coach has “built a lot of goodwill” with the organization.
Of course, Graziano warns that, say, a humiliating first-round loss in Tampa Bay could obviously change things. But even then, the reporter is unconvinced that the organization would move on from their coach.
McCarthy took over for Jason Garrett in 2020. Thanks mostly to instability at quarterback, the Cowboys finished only 6-10 during McCarthy’s first season at the helm. Dallas has fared a whole lot better over the past two-plus seasons, going 12-5 in both 2021 and 2022.
However, the Cowboys have only won a single playoff game between those two campaigns, losing twice to the 49ers. As a result, there was plenty of speculation heading into the season that McCarthy could be the scapegoat following another playoff dud.
The Cowboys are eyeing a similar regular-season performance in 2023, going 10-5 through their first 15 games. This followed an offseason where McCarthy parted ways with offensive coordinator Kellen Moore and took on play-calling duties. McCarthy is heading into lame duck status in 2024, so the Cowboys will have to make an offseason decision on the head coach one way or the other.
For what it’s worth, Jerry Jones unequivocally stated last year that the outcome of the postseason would not influence his decision on the head coach. We’ll see if the owner makes that kind of declaration in 2023.
More must-reads: