Dan Hamilton-USA TODAY Sports

Yikes. In the aftermath of Saturday night’s 4-3 overtime loss to the Boston Bruins, Toronto Maple Leafs’ captain John Tavares is facing a barrage of criticism from disappointed fans. The defeat marked a departure from the team’s trend of narrowly winning games in overtime or shootouts, and Tavares is now under scrutiny for his perceived lack of effort during a crucial moment in the extra period.

As a number of fans pointed out, it’s not a good look for the captain. In fact, it’s pretty awful.

As Tavares skated into the offensive zone, the turning point came when the puck was turned over by a falling William Nylander. Instead of aggressively pursuing the play, Tavares stood on the blue line for a few crucial seconds before slowly retreating into his own zone. This lack of urgency wasn’t why David Pastrnak got a shot on a breakaway, but it could have been why Brad Marchand of the Boston Bruins was left alone in front to seize an opportunity. Marchand scored an uncontested rebound and securing the victory.

While some sympathizers argue that Tavares may have been exhausted, the majority of fans are frustrated. It’s being perceived as a lack of commitment to the defensive effort. One critic expressed their disappointment, stating, “John Tavares should be stripped of his Captain ‘C’ for that defensive effort.” Another fan went further, branding Tavares as the “poster boy for ‘Apathy'” and asserting that he is the “worst Leafs Captain ever” with no leadership ability.

Tavares Is Going to Hear About This Terrible Play For Some Time

The sentiment online echoes the disappointment felt by Maple Leafs supporters. They had hoped for a different outcome in a closely contested game. Tavares now finds himself at the center of fan frustration, since he’s why the team lost in overtime. Now, questions surround his suitability as the team’s captain in the wake of this tough loss.

Fans will remember this if this winds up being a turning point in the season where the Leafs lose a few in a row. Tavares can only hope the Maple Leafs rebound and put some decisive wins together. It will be easier lack of hustle to overlook.

More must-reads:

TODAY'S BEST
Nuggets teach Timberwolves it's never easy to knock out the champion
Panthers come from behind to take Game 4 vs. Bruins
Hawks win 2024 NBA Draft Lottery
Watch: Padres star passes father on all-time home runs list
Terrion Arnold honors his mother in a unique way
Brad Keselowski breaks 110-race winless streak at Darlington
Watch: Manchester United ties record, highlighting club's ineptitude
Celtics' Jrue Holiday praises overlooked aspect of Jayson Tatum's game
Arturs Silovs' 42 saves lead Canucks past Oilers in Game 3
Braves star leaves game early due to left side soreness
Pacers blow out Knicks on Mother’s Day, even series at 2-2
Hawks GM 'shocked' that his team won the NBA Draft Lottery
Prolific former Brewers, A's slugger announces retirement
Saints to sign veteran offensive lineman
Smother's Day: Pacers shut down Knicks in first half of Game 4
Flyers goaltender suspended from international play for three years
Pistons make wrong kind of history at NBA Draft Lottery
Watch: Pacers C Myles Turner makes absurd three-pointer in first quarter vs. Knicks
Giants place key outfielder on injured list
Broncos release former Super Bowl champion WR