Image credit: ClutchPoints

The Edmonton Oilers beat t he Vegas Golden Knights 1-0 in overtime on Thursday to advance in the Stanley Cup Playoffs . After losing the first two games of the first round to the Los Angeles Kings, Edmonton is 8-1 in the postseason. The catalyst for the Oilers’ hot streak was replacing goalie Stuart Skinner with Calvin Pickard. But when Pickard suffered an injury during Game 2, they had to turn back to Skinner. After two shutouts to clinch the series, Connor McDavid hopes that Skinner has quieted the critics.

“Hopefully it shuts a lot of people up who were talking about him,” McDavid told the media, per Sportsnet. “We’ve always had belief in him. He comes in and pitches two shutouts. You can’t say enough good things.”

Oilers defenseman Darnell Nurse doubled down his his scrum. “Not much better than quieting all the people who talk s*** about you. We don’t win this series if he doesn’t step up and play the way he did. That’s a goaltender who took us to the Stanley Cup Final last year. We have a lot of belief in him.”

The Oilers did make the Stanley Cup Final last year with Skinner, but he created a lot of questions this season. His regular-season save percentage was .896, down from last year’s .905 mark. In the postseason, Skinner had a .901 save percentage and 2.45 goals-against average. In the first two games against the Kings, he allowed 11 goals with a .810 save percentage.

Will the Oilers go with Stuart Skinner or Calvin Pickard?

Edmonton Oilers goaltender Stuart Skinner (74) makes a save against the Vegas Golden Knights during the second period of game five of the second round of the 2025 Stanley Cup Playoffs at T-Mobile Arena. Stephen R. Sylvanie-Imagn Images

It would have been easy for Skinner to go off the rails after Game 3 against the Golden Knights. A solid performance was ruined by a buzzer-beater that went off of Leon Draisatil. But he responded with two consecutive shutouts to eliminate the Golden Knights.

Whether the Jets or Stars meet the Oilers in the Western Conference Final, they will have a big goalie decision to make. Do they go with a healthy Pickard, who is 6-0 in the Stanley Cup Playoffs? Or do they keep Skinner in after these two games? It’s a good problem to have for Kris Knoblauch headed into their third West Final in four years.

Skinner was the starter all year for the Oilers, manning the cage for 51 games this season. Pickard has only made eight playoff starts in his career, so trusting him is a risky endeavor. Skinner bested the Stars to reach the Stanley Cup Final last year.

More must-reads:

TODAY'S BEST
Watch: Julio Rodriguez's grand slam powers Mariners past White Sox 
Red Sox use extra base hits, bullpen depth to beat Mets
Wings should feel fine despite their 0-2 start to WNBA season
Watch: Marlins walk-off the Cubs in stunning fashion
New language revealed in latest proposal to ban tush push
Fred Warner extension shows linebackers are undervalued in today's NFL
Reds OF is the only player since 1900 with this impressive feat
IndyCar issues major penalty to Team Penske after rules violation in Indianapolis 500 qualifying
Panthers' Matthew Tkachuk calls out Toronto media live on air with 'Spittin' Chiclets'
Insider updates prediction for when Aaron Rodgers will sign with Steelers
Insider believes Maple Leafs would at least consider Auston Matthews trade
Eagles extend head coach Nick Sirianni
Nuggets star calls for big change to NBA playoffs
NASCAR power rankings: Million-dollar move puts Christopher Bell on top
Eagles hire mastermind behind Aaron Rodgers trade
WNBA looking into 'hateful fan comments' against Sky's Angel Reese
Three-time All-Star announces retirement from baseball
'He never once said a word to me': Packers HC Matt LaFleur breaks silence on disgruntled WR
Cubs manager confirms Matt Shaw-Miami news amid 3B trade report
Steelers learn more about Aaron Rodgers' personal issues amid NFL uncertainty

Want more Oilers news?

Join the hundreds of thousands of fans who start their day with Yardbarker's Morning Bark, the best newsletter in sports.