Cincinnati Bengals WR Ja'Marr Chase Denny Medley-USA TODAY Sports

Debating the NFL's top five position groups

Bucky Brooks has seen a lot of football as a player, scout and analyst for NFL Media. He recently put out a ranking of the five best position groups in football. It’s hard to argue with a man with Brook’s experience, but we will.

  • Best defensive front: Philadelphia Eagles

    Brooks notes that while the Eagles lost Javon Hargrave, they more than made up for it with their two first-round picks in the draft. He believes adding defensive tackle Jalen Carter and edge rusher Nolan Smith to an already potent defensive front will overwhelm opponents in 2023.

    Four players on Philadelphia’s defensive line had double-digit sacks last season, making it easy to rotate players, to keep them fresh at the end of games.

    However, the San Francisco 49ers make a strong case for the best defensive line. No team gave up fewer yards or points in 2022. Next year Hargrave gets to play next to Nick Bosa who led the league with 18.5 sacks last year. No team has a better 1-2 punch for 2023.

  • Best wide receivers: Cincinnati Bengals

    Brooks points to the complementary nature of Bengals’ receivers. Ja’Marr Chase is a burner, Tee Higgins has size and Tyler Boyd excels in the slot. So with a quarterback like Joe Burrow, why weren't any of them top-ten in yardage last year?

    Philadelphia and the Miami Dolphins had two top-10 receivers last year. Miami’s Jaylen Waddle led the league with 18.1 yards per catch while Tyreek Hill had the second-most yards. But Philly’s A.J. Brown tied for the third-most touchdowns among receivers. As long as they’re keeping score, Eagles receivers win this argument.
  • Best linebackers: San Francisco 49ers

    Brooks describes Fred Warner and Dre Greenlaw as the NFL’s most athletic and disruptive linebacker duo. Both can play coverage, defend underneath and line up against tight ends or running backs. Greenlaw isn’t as fast as Warner but is exceptional against the run.

    No argument here. Bosa gets all the attention, but Warner and Greenlaw are the heartbeat of the Niners defense

  • Best offensive line: Detroit Lions

    While Brooks has concerns with the right tackle spot, he has high praise for the rest of Detroit’s offensive line.  Without them, Jamaal Williams doesn’t lead all running backs in touchdowns last year.

    But according to Pro Football Focus, all five Eagles starters ranked inside the top 10 at their respective positions last year. Heading into Super Bowl LVII, the front five was responsible for only 11 of 38 sacks, the lowest number in the league. Detroit’s line is good, but their not on Philly’s level yet.

  • Best secondary: Miami Dolphins

    Cornerbacks Jalen Ramsey and Xavier Howard have a combined 10 Pro Bowl nominations and four first-team All-Pro designations, and Miami still drafted South Carolina cornerback Cam Smith with their first pick in this year’s draft.

    Ramsey will have to learn a new system, but with eight years in the league he'll have no problem. With a perfect mix of youth and experience, Brooks is right to name Miami’s secondary the best in football.

More must-reads:

TODAY'S BEST
Tyrese Haliburton’s father addresses his incident with Giannis Antetokounmpo
Patriots' Austin Hooper explains what teammates can expect from HC Mike Vrabel
Falcons to pick up star WR's fifth-year option
Falcons react to NFL levying fine against team and defensive coordinator Jeff Ulbrich
Insider names frontrunner in Browns' QB competition after drafting Shedeur Sanders
Yankees offense goes nuclear in blowout win
Giannis Antetokounmpo rips Tyrese Haliburton's father for 'disrespectful' act
Celtics make unique NBA playoff history in Game 5 win
How Steelers reportedly expect Aaron Rodgers saga will end
Juan Soto's bat speed decline threatens Mets' $765 million investment
NFL team executive expands on what Browns' Shedeur Sanders did wrong before draft
Insider suggests four-time Pro Bowl option for Steelers if Aaron Rodgers doesn't sign
Watch: Pacers, Tyrese Haliburton eliminate the Bucks in OT
Stanley Cup playoffs takeaways: Hurricanes advance, panic time for Maple Leafs
Jayson Tatum's historic game helps send Celtics to Eastern Conference semis
Pirates ace Paul Skenes explains why he's not concerned about potential injuries
Steelers may have found another steal in UDFA pool as Pittsburgh lands an athletic freak
49ers sign star TE to four-year extension
Spurs' Stephon Castle runs away with Rookie of the Year Award
Kings to make Doug Christie new head coach in full-circle moment

Want more sports news?

Join the hundreds of thousands of fans who start their day with Yardbarker's Morning Bark, the best newsletter in sports.