Three hottest seats on the Indianapolis Colts

The Indianapolis Colts (4-12-1) have high expectations that this offseason could be a turning point for the franchise. New HC Shane Steichen and an incoming rookie quarterback should make significant impacts. Even with plenty of optimism, Indianapolis can't afford a repeat of 2022.

Here are the three Colts on the hottest seats in 2023:

1. General manager Chris Ballard

Although Steichen's six-year deal may appear to secure Ballard's job for the foreseeable future, if owner Jim Irsay doesn't see improvement next year, he may consider dismissing the GM. In his exit news conference, Ballard admitted he failed last season and knows he can't fall short this offseason. 

The Colts hold the No. 4 overall pick in the 2023 NFL Draft and are in a position to trade up to No. 1. Regardless of which top prospect becomes Indianapolis' next QB, Ballard's future depends on his performance. 

Ballard must strengthen the Colts' supporting cast to prepare for their new signal-caller. The offensive line allowed the second-most sacks in the NFL last season (60). The situation isn't ideal for a young signal-caller, especially if their pick is the slim Alabama QB Bryce Young.

2. Wide receiver Michael Pittman Jr. 

After recording 1,082 receiving yards in 2021, Indianapolis hoped Pittman could establish himself as a top receiver, but he regressed like many others on the roster did. While poor QB play likely contributed to it, he still finished with the fewest receiving yards ever by a wideout with at least 99 receptions in a season. 

Pittman is eligible for an extension this offseason as he enters the final year of his rookie contract. He must surpass his second season's totals to earn top pay. Since whichever QB the Colts draft will likely lean on him, and the offense will be pass-friendly, he should have every opportunity to succeed.

3. Guard Quenton Nelson

In 2022, Nelson became the first player in Colts history to earn a Pro Bowl selection in each of his first five seasons. However, last season was also his worst as a professional. 

The highest-paid guard in NFL history earned the lowest Pro Football Focus grade of his career last season (68.4), ranking 20th among league guards. He allowed a career-high in QB hits (six), hurries (20) and pressures (31). His five sacks allowed were also a career-high and the fifth-most at his position.  

Injuries have plagued Nelson over the past two seasons, likely contributing to his recent decline. Before the 2021 season, he underwent three offseason surgeries and later missed time after suffering an ankle injury.  

Considering Nelson's high salary and injury history, it may be worth exploring his market next offseason if he or the Colts have another dismal season.