Despite the nostalgic charm of the original ‘Suits’ and a star-studded cast, ‘Suits LA’ failed to deliver. The highly anticipated spin-off fell flat just one season in, leaving fans and critics alike wondering what went wrong.
With its cancellation, ‘Suits LA’ joins the long list of TV spin-offs that simply couldn’t live up to their predecessors. But how did a show with such a strong foundation, backed by an iconic franchise, miss the mark so drastically? Let’s explore the key reasons why the show failed to connect with audiences and critics.
What Went Wrong With ‘Suits LA’?
When ‘Suits LA’ was announced, expectations were understandably high. Suits had just experienced a massive resurgence on Netflix, dominating streaming charts for weeks. Loyal fans were excited to dive back into the world of high-stakes legal drama. With Stephen Amell cast as the lead, Ted Black, and cameo appearances from fan favorites like Gabriel Macht’s Harvey Specter and Rick Hoffman’s Louis Litt, the show seemed to have all the ingredients for success.
However, the excitement quickly turned into disappointment. The show premiered in February 2025 with 2.53 million viewers tuning in, which was groundbreaking. Unfortunately, the numbers plummeted episode by episode, with the finale scraping just under a million viewers. It wasn’t just the ratings that tanked; the reviews were just as brutal. Rotten Tomatoes handed the show a dismal 39% rating, with critics citing lackluster writing, dull character arcs, and a general absence of the charm that made ‘Suits’ a hit.
The central plot follows Ted Black, a former New York prosecutor who sets up a boutique law firm in Los Angeles. The formula echoed that of the original show, but it lacked the originality that made Suits stand out. The writing felt formulaic, and the characters didn’t pop. The magic wasn’t there. And then there was the casting issue. While Stephen Amell is a capable actor, many viewers felt his portrayal lacked the charisma and intellectual edge that the role demanded. The chemistry among the characters also didn’t measure up to the original.
‘Suits LA’ Was Banking Too Hard On Nostalgia, Which Just Didn’t Hit Home
One of the biggest lessons from the ‘Suits LA’ failure is that nostalgia alone isn’t enough. While the show leaned heavily on familiar faces and stylistic similarities, it forgot to offer something new. Viewers today crave fresh content. Simply recreating an old formula doesn’t satisfy an audience that has become more discerning and spoiled for choice in the age of streaming.
Moreover, the weekly release format hurt the show. While the original Suits thrived in a different TV era, today’s audiences expect binge-worthy content. In a world where entire seasons drop at once and fans can devour them in a weekend, waiting a week for an underwhelming episode just didn’t cut it. The pacing suffered, the tension dwindled, and interest faded.
Moreover, the attempt to strike a balance between fan service and originality is delicate, and ‘Suits LA’ leaned too far into the former without delivering. Fans also noticed the tonal shift. While the original ‘Suits’ was set in the sleek, no-nonsense world of New York law, with sharp dialogue and high stakes, ‘Suits LA’ struggled to define its tone. Was it trying to be dramatic? Light-hearted? Procedural? The lack of a clear identity made it difficult for viewers to invest emotionally.
More must-reads: