NCAA faces $4 million lawsuit by former player over lost NIL

“This valuation reflects the market value of an upperclassman with a proven performance record and high visibility,” the complaint reads, citing projections from Spyre Sports Group, Tennessee’s NIL collective.

Zeigler, who averaged 13.6 points and a league-leading 7.4 assists last season, led Tennessee to a second straight Elite Eight. He became the program’s all-time assists leader and the first SEC player ever to log 1,550 points, 700 assists, 350 rebounds, and 250 steals. Despite his accolades, Zeigler didn’t receive an invite to the NBA Draft Combine or G League Elite Camp.

Now, he wants to return to college hoops—and cash in on his peak value.

The suit takes aim at the NCAA’s policy that allows student-athletes five calendar years to play four seasons—unless they redshirt. Zeigler, who never redshirted, argues that this system unfairly penalizes players for choices made by coaches, not students.

“All NCAA athletes should be eligible to compete and earn NIL compensation during each year of the five-year window—not just those selected to redshirt,” the complaint states.

Zeigler is represented by Litson PLLC and Garza Law Firm. The legal team is pushing for an injunction to let him play during the 2025–2026 season while pursuing a graduate degree.

“This is about fairness,” one NIL advisor familiar with the case said. “Zakai isn’t asking for extra eligibility—he’s asking to use the window the NCAA already gives, just like everyone else.”

If the court rules in Zeigler’s favor, the implications could rock the NCAA and redefine the market for upperclassmen athletes overnight.