Over the last few days, a segment of college football fans have been discussing a hypothetical six-school trade between the ACC and Big 12 - an idea that was proposed in Stewart Mandel's mailbag on The Athletic.
In this trade, the ACC would get Cincinnati, UCF, and West Virginia, while the Big 12 would receive Cal, SMU, and Stanford.
This week, a Mailbag reader suggested a six-team conference swap that almost makes too much sense.https://t.co/ThySch4edK pic.twitter.com/WNJavqgXxK
— Stewart Mandel (@slmandel) July 3, 2025
In terms of the value each conference would be receiving, it seems like a pretty fair deal. The ACC would probably be considered the "winners" of the trade by the simple fact of WVU having the largest fan base and best all-around athletic program of the six schools involved.
The problem is, it would be a step down for WVU.
They'd enter a league that doesn't have a very friendly TV deal and also has a few of its top members potentially looking for a way out. Yes, the ACC's recent settlement with Clemson and Florida State keeps the two programs happy at the moment, but that doesn't totally prevent them from making a move down the line. The exit fee drops to $75 million in 2030, which isn't all that much when you consider Oklahoma and Texas paid the Big 12 a combined $100 million in 2024.
ACC year-by-year exit fees, if any schools want to bolt
— Brett McMurphy (@Brett_McMurphy) July 3, 2025
$165 million in 2025-26
$147 million in 2026-27
$129 million in 2027-28
$111 million in 2028-29
$93 million in 2029-30
$75 million in 2030-31
$75 million in 2031-32
$75 million in 2032-33
$75 million in 2033-34
$75 million…
Although this "trade" is fantasy world talk, it wouldn't be a good thing for WVU. By the time they'd get settled in the ACC, the league may be on the verge of collapsing.
Geographically speaking, it makes all the sense in the world. Who wouldn't want to see Pitt, Virginia Tech, Syracuse, and Louisville on the schedule every year? Maybe one day, conference realignment will actually make sense, but I wouldn't hold my breath.
WVU Player Ratings Leaked in College Football 26 Dynasty Mode YouTube Video
Javon Small Drops Dimes and Turns Some Heads in Debut with Memphis Grizzlies
Erik Stevenson Explodes Off the Bench and Buries the Spurs from Deep
Between The Eers: Where the Media Would Rank WVU in the Big 12 Poll
More must-reads:
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!