LSU head coach Brian Kelly was right to go for it. Let's get that out of the way.
Kelly was immediately criticized for his decision to keep the Tigers offense on the field for two short-yardage situations on fourth down in the first half, but in a 45-24 loss, two field goals would have been meaningless.
LSU needed touchdowns, and in short-yardage situations, the Tigers should have been able to convert. It's troubling for the Tigers how Florida State manhandled them in the trenches, but that doesn't mean those decisions were the wrong ones.
That by no means absolves Kelly from any blame in LSU's loss, however. In fact, his biggest blunder came well before the opening kick.
LSU lost this game when they moved Harold Perkins to off-ball LB back in the spring
— Trevor Sikkema (@TampaBayTre) September 4, 2023
Preseason First-Team All-SEC outside linebacker Harold Perkins Jr. was so poorly used in the opener that the NCAA should allow for his immediate transfer.
If Kelly's job is to get his players in the best position to succeed, his decision to play Perkins, an elite pass-rusher, primarily in coverage was by far his most egregious error on Sunday night.
The move had a major impact on Perkins' game, as CBS Sports' Bud Elliott noted.
PFF graded Harold Perkins as the worst player on LSU's defense last night 19th of 19.
— Bud Elliott (@BudElliott3) September 4, 2023
That seems... interesting? Doesn't really match what I saw?
I thought it was more "is it right to use him in this role instead of pass rushing" than "he was bad."
Was he bad? That bad?
Perkins is arguably the most talented player on LSU's defense and certainly far from the worst, but his usage put him in a position where he couldn't thrive.
LSU's Harold Perkins had a career-high 28 snaps in coverage while only rushing the passer seven times last night against FSU
— Steve Palazzolo (@PFF_Steve) September 4, 2023
Seven pass rushes for Perkins? We understand Florida State quarterback Jordan Travis is a dynamic dual-threat at quarterback, but he was feasting against LSU's secondary. The only times he struggled was when he was under duress, which Perkins would have certainly put him under more often if given the opportunity.
Data from Pro Football Focus shows Perkins averaged 13.5 pass rushes per game in 13 appearances last season and finished the year with 41 total pressures and 10 sacks. (Official stats gave Perkins 7.5 sacks last year, but PFF credits half-sacks as whole ones.) His 90.9 pass-rush grade was the best on the team.
Perkins' role against Florida State didn't come out of thin air. It was something Kelly planned for, and it backfired as epically as possible.
The decision was roundly criticized on social media, including by 247Sports recruiting analyst Cooper Petagna and ESPN NFL Draft analyst Matt Miller.
LSU’s decision to neutralize Harold Perkins by playing him primarily off ball is head scratching. Essentially taking your best player and prospect of perimeter pass rush out of the game. Need to give ‘em the green light and cut him loose.
— Cooper Petagna (@cpetagna247) September 4, 2023
LSU has one of the most explosive pass-rushers in the nation and they're asking Harold Perkins to stand there and spy Jordan Travis as he throws bombs down field instead of rushing him.
— Matt Miller (@nfldraftscout) September 4, 2023
I don't get it.
The blowout Week 1 loss revealed the Tigers have a lot of work to do if they're going to repeat as SEC West champions.
Putting Perkins in the position he knows best would be a good place to start.
More must-reads:
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!