BYU loses two-way transfer to Big 12 rival

Originally posted on Athlon Sports | By Steven Corder | Last updated May 4, 2025 4:28 PM ET

In a twist that’s sending shockwaves through Provo, freshman Carson Suesue is packing his bags for Stillwater. The versatile former Granger High star is officially transferring from BYU to Oklahoma State — a blow to Cougar fans hoping to watch the Utah product blossom in blue and white.

A Rare Athletic Talent Slips Away

At 6-foot-5 and 240 pounds, Suesue was one of BYU’s most intriguing spring roster additions. Originally recruited as a linebacker after returning from a two-year religious mission, he’s now making yet another position switch — this time to tight end for the Cowboys. His high school résumé reads like a Madden create-a-player: 3,295 passing yards, 33 touchdowns, 709 rushing yards, and 9 rushing scores as a senior quarterback. Losing an athlete that dynamic, especially one just beginning his college career, stings deeply.

Timing Hurts Even More

This move comes just months after Suesue joined the program and took part in BYU’s spring activities. His departure not only disrupts the Cougars’ linebacker depth chart, but also raises questions about player retention and fit in the post-mission transition period. Fans will remember that BYU just gained former Oklahoma State DT Justin Kirkland through the portal — a trade of talent that’s now drawn headlines for all the wrong reasons.

A Big 12 Rival Benefits

With Oklahoma State’s tight end room undergoing a revamp — including the recent exit of Jordan Owens and the arrival of Utah ties in new position coach DJ Tialavea — Suesue walks into a situation with opportunity. The Cowboys have brought in two other portal tight ends, but Suesue’s size and athleticism may offer immediate upside. BYU, meanwhile, loses a raw but rare talent to a conference opponent they’ll have to face.

Bottom Line for Cougar Nation:

This one hurts. Suesue was more than just a project; he was a symbol of the kind of athleticism BYU needs to compete in the Big 12. Now, he’s suiting up for a team that stands in their way. If Kalani Sitake and staff want to avoid more portal surprises, it’s time to double down on culture and development.

This article first appeared on Athlon Sports and was syndicated with permission.

More must-reads: