Yardbarker
x
‘It’s Still a Circus’: Deion Sanders, Colorado Called out by Big 12 Assistant
Troy Taormina-Imagn Images

With reigning Heisman Trophy winner Travis Hunter and All-Big 12 quarterback Shedeur Sanders off to the NFL, coach Deion Sanders enters Year 3 at Colorado with wide-ranging expectations and plenty of questions.

The Buffaloes showed proof of concept under Sanders with a 9-4 record in 2024, their best season since 2016. However, turnover at quarterback and, in Hunter’s case, a playmaker on both sides of the ball, could spell regression in Boulder this fall.

Sanders stayed active in the transfer portal, adding a quarterback, weapons at the skill positions and offensive line help in order to compete with Arizona State, Texas Tech, Baylor and Kansas State in the Big 12 race. But another coach in the conference called into question Colorado’s continued portal reliance and the environment of the program.

“They’ve turned over a ton in the portal, and they’re trying to make it out like it’s a competition-based result, but they’re really going to struggle on the offensive line because of transfers again,” an anonymous Big 12 assistant coach said in Athlon Sports’ 2025 College Football Preview magazine. “It’s still a circus. That’s not an insult to Deion, but it is.”

These comments were made in the Buffaloes’ exclusive scouting report in Athlon’s annual magazine, which is available for purchase online and at newsstands nationwide.

It’s true that Colorado overhauled its roster in the portal with 30 new arrivals. The Buffs built in the trenches with defensive lineman Jeheim Otis (Alabama) and offensive linemen Zylon Crisler (Illinois) and Xavier Hill (Memphis). They also added quarterbacks Kaidon Salter (Liberty) and four-star freshman Julian Lewis, along with wide receivers Sincere Brown (Campbell) and Joseph Williams (Tulsa).

“Salter is a good fit for the stuff they ran last year,” the Big 12 assistant said, “and they have a lot of good transfer wideouts.”

Despite the reinforcements Sanders secured in the winter and spring windows, Colorado is not expected to contend for the conference championship. A difficult schedule might even make bowl eligibility an uphill battle.

“It will be interesting to see how Deion manages the culture here,” the anonymous coach said. “This is a roster with big holes and a lot of questions.”

One spot where the Buffaloes seem to be set is defensive back. Cornerback D.J. McKinney headlines a talented group that includes Colton Hood opposite him, Preston Hodge at nickel and Tawfiq Byward (South Florida) at safety.

“Hunter is so good, he overshadowed a really good position group in the secondary,” the Big 12 coach said. “Right now, that is their strength. If they can rework the front, the defense might be better overall.”

But with Shedeur Sanders fighting for the starting job on the Cleveland Browns and Shilo Sanders battling to make the Tampa Bay Buccaneers roster, outsiders are still curious about Deion Sanders’ future at Colorado.

“With his sons gone,” the anonymous assistant said, “this is the year you really wonder what Deion’s long-term plan is.”

This article first appeared on Athlon Sports and was syndicated with permission.

More must-reads:

Customize Your Newsletter

Yardbarker +

Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!