There seems to be a never-ending debate going on when it comes to the College Football Playoff. How many teams should get in? Why are the SEC and Big Ten conferences trying to ruin everything? How much should strength of schedule impact seeding and which conferences get potential auto-bids?
There are so many questions still unanswered when it comes to the future of the College Football Playoff, but Kirby Smart made sure his view on things were clear on Tuesday during his media availability at the SEC Spring Meetings. He may not know exactly where things are going, and the questions on the playoff won't be answered right now, but he wants to make the game better, no matter what.
"Yeah, I think I have a good understanding of where [the College Football Playoff] is and the decisions that have to be made–which I don't think those get answered here [at SEC spring meetings]...I'm not looking at it in self-preservation mode, which happens a lot in college football...You're trying to constantly sustain the game and make the game better and not just do it for what's best for me (or Georgia)."
There's been a lot of finger-pointing when it comes to the SEC, the Big Ten, the commissioners among other important figures, and who should carry the blame for all the change in college football. Many in the media and a rising contingent of college football fans are fed up with too many people at the top serving their own self interests (which is likely why coach Smart brought up the self-preservation talk). Clearly, Kirby Smart wants to make sure that the College Football Playoff–however it looks in the future–fits what is best for the game in its entirety.
However, despite wanting the playoff to be what is "best for the game", Kirby Smart did also hammer home what many in the SEC have already said about the strength of the conference and teams like Ole Miss, South Carolina, and Alabama missing the playoff:
"It blows me away [in other sports] when the SEC can end up with 13 of 16, 14 of 16 [teams in the playoff formats], and they're larger pools–but when you look at what they're able to do and there's no outcry. There's nobody beating the drum saying that it's completely unfair. They do a lot of things based on RPI. A lot of things based on strength of schedule, and they reward teams for that. I have a hard time seeing Ole Miss, Alabama, South Carolina not being [considered] among the best [college football] teams last year. And to me, that's a big part of the SEC."
Georgia’s Kirby Smart on College Football Playoff selection process: “There’s no outcry, saying it’s unfair when SEC gets 13 of 16 teams in basketball tournament by using RPI. I have a hard time thinking Ole Miss, South Carolina & Alabama (who all missed last year's CFP) were not…
— Brett McMurphy (@Brett_McMurphy) May 27, 2025
It is a bit strange how 13 SEC baseball teams made the tournament this spring and 14 SEC basketball teams qualified for March Madness, yet there doesn't seem to be much outcry about that. Yes, those sports have different playoff pools and qualifying criteria, but the outrage over football has certainly been louder when it comes to the SEC and Big Ten.
A lot of it has to do with strength of schedule and the debate there. Most non-SEC conferences want teams like Georgia, Alabama, and others to play nine conference games, using that as a constant point of contention in playoff and quality of schedule debates. However, Smart chose to bring that one up on his own again too, highlighting the irrationality of such an argument:
"Would we have been better off not playing Clemson last year and playing another SEC game to make nine [conference] games? How would that have been better for the SEC? How would that have been better for Georgia? I don't think it would have. Those teams you play outside your conference verify your strength."
It's clear that Kirby Smart wants what is best for the game of football, but he also recognizes how absurd any argument typically is in limiting the number of SEC teams to make the playoff. And he definitely doesn't like the idea of missing out on playing a team like Clemson just so Georgia gets another conference game either. SEC (and all) teams should play tough games and get rewarded for it. It's pretty simple.
There's not going to be a magic pill that ends all of the College Football Playoff debates, but it's good to hear one of the major voices in the sport weighing in. Hopefully rational voices like Kirby Smart (among others at the top of the sport) win the day, leading to a College Football Playoff future that is truly best for the sport in its entirety–whatever that ends up looking like in the end.
We'll be back with more Georgia Bulldogs coverage here at A to Z Sports soon! Follow me (@FF_TravisM) and A to Z Sports (@AtoZSportsNFL) on X for all the latest football news!
If you want to see more on the College Football Playoff in the full SEC Spring Meetings press conference with Kirby Smart you can find that in the video below.
More must-reads:
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!