The Texas Longhorns were atop the college football world for all of one week before becoming the first preseason No. 1 team to lose its season opener since 1990.
With a chance to avenge their College Football Playoff Semifinal loss from a year ago, and assert themselves as the best team in the sport, the Longhorns ended up losing 14-7 to the No. 3 Ohio State Buckeyes.
The common takeaway for many is how poorly former No. 1 overall recruit and new Texas quarterback Arch Manning played. The nephew of Peyton and Eli Manning had 38 yards passing by the time the fourth quarter rolled around, before finishing the game 17-of-30 for 170 yards with a touchdown and a pass.
Realistically, Manning missed throws he should've made, Matt Patricia's defense had his mind in a blender and Texas got things going far too late. With that being said, there seemed to be an underlying issue with the Texas offense that is starting to have more light shed on it, which is Steve Sarkisian's play-calling.
Renowned as one of the more creative minds in football, Sarkisian has crafted an offense that is as complex as any, and when it's working, it's beautiful. That being said, when it comes to matchups against top teams, Sarkisian is frequently outcoached as the Longhorns are 1-6 against top-five teams dating back to 2022.
Sarkisian frequently overthinks things and plays much more conservatively than he would against an average opponent. In addition to his hesitancy, Sarkisian's offense frequently struggles out of the gate.
On Texas Football's CJ Vogel reported on Tuesday that Texas has scored just two touchdowns after receiving first in 20 games where they have received the ball first.
In 31 games since 2023, Texas has received the opening kickoff 20 times.
— CJ Vogel (@CJVogel_OTF) September 2, 2025
They’ve converted that opening possession to a touchdown just twice. https://t.co/kwb2ymkwFs
In addition to concerning starts, Texas also struggles tremendously to finish drives with touchdowns once it gets into the red zone.
As confirmed by the Athletic's Chris Vannini, the Longhorns ranked No. 65 in 2022, No. 120 in 2023, and No. 54 last season when it comes to the percentage of times they scored touchdowns in the red zone. They aren't off to a hot start this year either, as they went 0-of-2 against Ohio State, with one of their chances seeing them get stuffed at the one yard line.
While there's certainly a possibility that Sarkisian busts his own slump, and it's almost a guarantee that Texas finds a rhythm with three Group of Five opponents next on the docket, Sarkisian relinquishing his play-calling duties may be in the best interest of the team.
The struggles have gone from a coincidence to a trend, and with Texas not having a talent issue, there are really only so many changes that can be made to elevate the program to the level of being champions.
Although Sarkisin doesn't necessarily have to nor has he shown any signs of wanting to, head coaches giving up play-calling duties to take on a CEO role has become more common as of late.
Ohio State's Ryan Day did so last year after hiring former Oregon/UCLA head coach Chip Kelly as the offensive coordinator, and the team went on to win the title. Florida State's Mike Norvell brought in former Auburn/UCF head coach Gus Malzahn to handle play-calling this year, and the Seminoles thrashed No. 8 Alabama in Week 1 despite being double-digit favorites.
Unless Sarkisian can overcome this constant struggle himself, the Longhorns may consistently find themselves a couple of plays away from winning a title.
More must-reads:
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!