
The legal battle over the 2008 F1 championship, one of the most dramatic title fights in history, took another turn this week as lawyers from F1 Management(FOM) argued that Felipe Massa’s case “will fail.”
The Brazilian ex-driver has claimed that the infamous 2008 Singapore Grand Prix, later known as “Crashgate,” unfairly cost him the world championship. Massa argues that Formula 1 and the FIA knew of Renault’s deliberate crash, which led to Fernando Alonso’s win and Hamilton’s crucial points gain, but failed to act swiftly enough, altering the championship’s outcome.
However, Annelise Day KC, representing FOM, dismissed these claims in written submissions to the court. She stated that Massa’s pursuit of the title was not derailed by the safety car triggered by Nelson Piquest Jr.’s crash, but by “a series of subsequent racing errors by him and his team during the remaining 47 laps of the race.”
In one of the most direct rebukes of Massa’s legal argument to date, Day asserted that Lewis Hamilton was simply the better driver over the course of the season.
“The simple fact is that over the course of both the Singapore Grand Prix and across the 2008 season, Mr Hamilton outperformed Mr Massa and everyone else,” she said.
Hamilton famously won his first world title that year in dramatic fashion, clinching fifth place in the final corner of the Brazilian Grand Prix to edge out Massa by a single point.
The case has brought together three major entities, Bernie Ecclestone, the FIA, and FOM, all defending against Massa’s attempt to have the title results revisited.
Their joint position emphasizes that decisions from past championships are final and that revisiting them would set a dangerous precedent for the sport. Ecclestone himself has previously admitted to knowing about Renault’s actions earlier today than publicly acknowledged, but now maintains that Massa’s claim is without legal foundation.
If the court accepts the defense’s motion to strike out the case, Massa’s long campaign to reclaim the 2008 title could effectively and before reaching trial.
For Massa, the case represents more than a title, it’s about restoring what he believes was taken from him unfairly. But with legal experts describing his case as “ambitious,” and with FOM’s latest statement framing it as a futile rewrite of history, his battle appears increasingly uphill.
More must-reads:
+
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!