Max Verstappen’s pursuit of a win in the Saudi Arabian GP took a dramatic hit. What initially appeared to be a thrilling wheel-to-wheel battle between the Dutchman and Oscar Piastri quickly escalated into a controversial penalty decision that left Red Bull fuming and sparked debates across the paddock. But was the punishment fair—or was Verstappen simply unlucky?
The stewards handed Verstappen a five-second penalty for gaining a lasting advantage after running wide at Turn 1, an incident triggered during his battle with Piastri. At the heart of the decision was whether Verstappen had been pushed off the track—or whether he voluntarily exceeded track limits and benefited from it.
According to The Race’s detailed breakdown, Piastri had fulfilled all four critical criteria—set out in the FIA’s secret driving standards document—for a legitimate overtake. Which means, his front axle was alongside Verstappen's mirror, his car fully under control, he didn't force Verstappen off track and he stayed within the track limits himself.
Telemetry showed Verstappen entered the corner with too much speed and didn’t try to slow down as he ran wife. Instead, he floored it through the runoff and emerged ahead. From the stewards’ perspective, that was enough to warrant a penalty.
Red Bull, however, fiercely disagreed. Team principal Christian Horner arrived at his post-race media briefing armed with “new evidence”—a still from a pre, the footage showed Verstappen ahead of Piastri at the apex, suggesting he was owed space. But the stewards believed the image reflected Verstappen’s positioning later in the corner—after he had already run off.
As The Race’s analysis pointed out, McLaren team boss Andrea Stella remained calm. He said the matter was clear cut: Piastru earned the convened, stayed within limits, and executed the move cleanly. He even cited a recent example in Bahrain, where McLaren voluntarily instructed Lando Norris to give the position back to Lewis Hamilton despite ambiguity—something Red Bull refused to do in Jeddah.
Viaplay: It's clear you don't agree with the penalty, so I want to talk about it
— Verstappen News (@verstappenews) April 20, 2025
Max: "No."
Viaplay: But it was deciding-
Max: "No. It doesn't matter. I don't want to talk about it."
Viaplay: But why not?
Max: "Because I don't want to." pic.twitter.com/9CLK5VuA2a
While Red Bull seems unlikely to push for a formal review, they reportedly want clarity from the FIA on racing rules—particularly how responsibility is shared in overtaking scenarios. In a season where overtaking is harder than ever due to dirty air and low tyre degradation, first lap battles like this one may increasingly determine race and championship outcomes.
Verstappen’s aggressive approach at Turn 1 might have sealed his fate. And crucially, it also overshadowed the fact that a poor start had left him vulnerable in the first place. The four-time world champion may feel wronged, but in the eyes of the stewards—and the sport’s regulations—the penalty stood. And in a title fight separated by mere points, that five-second sanction could loom large.
More must-reads:
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!