The Browns QB room has been the most talked about in the league ever since the team elected to draft Dillon Gabriel in the third round and Shedeur Sanders in the fifth.
There's been no shortage of headlines in terms of the former Colorado star and Cleveland's handling of the entire situation. Especially with reports surfacing that Browns head coach Kevin Stefanski never wanted to draft Shedeur to begin with.
As much as Shedeur impressed in his first taste of preseason action — throwing for 138 yards and two scores in the franchise's 30-10 win over the Panthers — his performance was equally as disappointing in this weekend's finale.
Sanders completed just three of his six second half pass attempts for a total of 14 yards while also taking five sacks — including a brutal 24-yard loss that took the Browns offense out of midfield.
One of the most controversial things the Browns decided to do on Saturday was pull Sanders ahead of the team's final two-minute drill in order to give Tyler Huntley a look.
That drew a reaction from many across the NFL world, including recently retired Pro Bowl quarterback Derek Carr who had this to say on X:
"I need to understand why we don't get to see @ShedeurSanders run this 2 minute drill? Wouldn't you want to see your young QB operate in this situation? Get him more reps for the future? I didn't see the whole game so maybe he already showed enough? Help me understand this…"
Carr wasn't the only one to take Stefanski and others to task, however, as two-time MVP and Pro Football Hall of Famer Kurt Warner also expressed disappointment in Cleveland's handling (or mishandling) of their young signal-callers.
Taking to social media, the ex-QB turned NFL Network analyst shared how he wishes Shedeur and Dillon Gabriel had gotten the same opportunities to prove themselves this summer.
"I was really looking forward to the competition between Dillon Gabriel & Shedeur Sanders in last preseason game, I know it plays out like this sometimes, but a bummer that both didn’t have the same opps to make plays!" Warner exclaimed. "DG played well again but had good opps to make plays, SS didn’t those same opps so it was hard to make much of an assessment!"
I was really looking forward to the competition between Dillon Gabriel & Shedeur Sanders in last preseason game, I know it plays out like this sometimes, but a bummer that both didn’t have the same opps to make plays! DG played well again but had good opps to make plays, SS…
— Kurt Warner (@kurt13warner) August 24, 2025
Clearly the Browns have gone about things in a unique way when it comes to their approach to the position. And it's sounding like they could keep four QBs on the roster heading into Week 1.
Joe Flacco will remain the team's starter for the time being, but right now it's looking like Cleveland will give Gabriel every opportunity to remain ahead of Sanders on the depth chart.
More must-reads:
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!