Brett Davis-Imagn Images

Paul Finebaum Sounds Alarm Over College Football’s Future Amid Transfer Portal Chaos

Originally posted on Athlon Sports | By Tristan Afshar | Last updated May 19, 2025 11:24 AM ET

College football has undergone massive shifts in recent years, but longtime ESPN analyst Paul Finebaum believes one change in particular is sending the sport toward a dangerous future.

The growing dominance of the NCAA transfer portal — once a tool for player mobility — has now become a symbol of what Finebaum considers a deeper problem. And in his words, the sport may be nearing a breaking point.

“I think college football is at a tipping point, and I think what is going on now is an existential threat to the future of the game!”

That one sentence, delivered with urgency and conviction, struck a nerve across the college football landscape.

Finebaum says the transfer portal is destabilizing the entire sport

The transfer portal was originally introduced to give student-athletes more freedom — to escape toxic coaching situations, find better playing time, or land in a system that suits their development. But with NIL money now heavily involved, many feel the portal has turned into free agency with virtually no rules.

Finebaum’s warning wasn’t about nostalgia — it was about survival. With entire rosters flipping from one season to the next, coaches scrambling to fill holes left by last-minute exits, and boosters playing an outsized role in roster decisions, the college game is looking less like a tradition-rich institution and more like a business in chaos.

"I think college football is at a tipping point, and I think what is going on now is an existential threat to the future of the game!" @finebaum on why the transfer portal is negatively affecting the future of college football! @WJOX945

Full interview: https://t.co/fULFehEWpM pic.twitter.com/TEaYebCL0K
— McElroy and Cubelic in the Morning (@macandcube) May 19, 2025

Finebaum has been vocal in the past about issues facing the sport, but this time, the message carried more weight. It’s not just about losing players — it’s about losing the very identity of college football.

Whether the NCAA or the conferences decide to address the transfer portal soon could determine if the sport regains control — or keeps spiraling further away from what made it great in the first place.

This article first appeared on Athlon Sports and was syndicated with permission.

More must-reads: