Kirby Lee-Imagn Images

'She's born for the Bills Mafia' — Hailee Steinfeld has already cemented herself as the first lady of Buffalo

Originally posted on A to Z Sports | By Sophie Weller | Last updated Aug 4, 2025 5:36 PM ET

Peanut butter and jelly, chicken wings with bleu cheese, and Josh and Hailee Steinfeld. All three are perfect combinations and a comfort for at least some members of the Bills Mafia. Buffalo's star couple has been a perfect fit, giving fans some viral moments along the way.

And Steinfeld recently received high praise from a fellow actor, who even admitted that he thinks she is the perfect person for this passionate fanbase, which he just so happens to be a part of, too.

"She's all in, we watched the game last year together, and all in," Chad Michael Murray said during an appearance on Good Morning Football. "She's born for the Bills Mafia."

If it wasn't obvious already, @HaileeSteinfeld is ALL IN on #BillsMafia (@ChadMMurray confirms)@TheRokuChannel | Check local listings pic.twitter.com/214ta1wOMW
— Good Morning Football (@gmfb) August 4, 2025

Steinfeld has been supporting Allen at every turn, specifically when he won the 2024 NFL MVP award. The two even shared a sweet moment, with Steinfeld beaming with pride. Allen also took a moment to thank her in his acceptance speech.

“My fiancé Hailee, you’ve been my rock, you’re my best friend,” he said.

Winning an MVP and then marrying a superhero is mightily impressive for Allen, and now both have their eyes set on a Super Bowl for Buffalo. Steinfeld firmly understands just how important the fanbase is to the organization and has welcomed them with more than open arms.

Plus, she's also proved herself with an epic roast of the other AFC East teams back in February.

When asked how many teams are in the AFC East, she responded with “The Buffalo Bills, and the Bills’ three sons.”

We already have an Allen Street; when is Steinfeld Street coming?

This article first appeared on A to Z Sports and was syndicated with permission.

More must-reads: