Should Insomniac Step Aside? Why Spider-Man Deserves a New Studio’s Vision For 2025 Gaming

The Budget Problem That Nobody Wants To Talk About

Let’s address the elephant in the room – or should I say the $315 million spider in the room. When Insomniac got hit with that massive data breach in 2023, we learned some pretty eye-watering details about Marvel’s Spider-Man 2’s budget. Three hundred and fifteen million dollars. That’s not a typo, folks. That’s enough money to fund several indie games, buy a small country, or apparently, make one really expensive Spider-Man game.

Ted Price, Insomniac’s founder, seems optimistic about finding solutions to these ballooning costs, talking about getting “creative” and examining production pipelines. But honestly? When your game costs more than some Marvel movies, maybe it’s time to step back and ask if there’s a more efficient way to do things.

Why A Different Studio Could Be Exactly What Spider-Man Needs

Here’s where things get interesting. Insomniac has become incredibly comfortable with their Spider-Man formula, and while comfort breeds consistency, it doesn’t always breed innovation. They’ve collectively decided to “double down on story-driven character action games,” which sounds great on paper but also sounds like they’re playing it safe.

Remember when Ultimate Spider-Man was developed by Treyarch? That game had a completely different art style, introduced Venom as a playable character, and felt genuinely unique in the superhero gaming landscape. Or think about how different studios brought fresh perspectives to Batman – Rocksteady gave us the Arkham series, while WB Games Montréal offered their own take with Origins.

The Fresh Perspective Argument

Spider-Man is one of the most versatile characters in all of comics. The guy has been a teenager, an adult, a mentor, part of teams, a loner, and everything in between. Limiting him to one studio’s interpretation, no matter how good that interpretation is, feels like we’re missing out on potential goldmine experiences.

What if a studio known for incredible traversal mechanics like the folks behind Titanfall took a crack at web-slinging? What if a team famous for roguelike elements decided to explore the multiverse concept that’s so hot right now? What if developers known for their humor brought us a more comedic Spider-Man experience that leaned into Peter Parker’s quip-heavy fighting style?

The Innovation Stagnation

Don’t get me wrong – Insomniac’s games are polished to a mirror shine. But when you’ve played one, you’ve kind of played them all in terms of basic mechanics and structure. The formula works, sure, but it’s becoming predictable. Open world, towers to unlock, side missions that feel like busy work, and a main story that follows the same three-act structure we’ve seen before.

A different studio might approach the source material from a completely different angle. Maybe they’d focus more on Peter Parker’s daily life and make the superhero stuff feel more impactful when it happens. Maybe they’d create a more intimate, smaller-scale Spider-Man game that focuses on neighborhood-level crime rather than world-ending threats.

The Success Trap

Insomniac has fallen into what I like to call the “success trap.” Their Spider-Man games sell incredibly well, get great reviews, and make everyone happy. So why rock the boat? Well, because sometimes the boat needs rocking to reach new shores.

Look at how different studios have handled other major franchises. Call of Duty rotates between multiple developers, and while that brings its own problems, it also means we get different approaches to the same core concept. Assassin’s Creed has been handled by various Ubisoft studios, leading to dramatically different experiences from Black Flag to Origins to Mirage.

What Another Studio Could Bring

Imagine if Remedy Entertainment, known for their narrative brilliance and reality-bending mechanics, took on Spider-Man. We could get a game that really dives deep into the psychological aspects of being a superhero, complete with their signature supernatural elements.

Or picture Platinum Games bringing their over-the-top action sensibilities to a Spider-Man title. The combat would be absolutely insane, and they’d probably find ways to make web-slinging even more dynamic than Insomniac has.

Hell, what about Arkane Studios? Their expertise with immersive sims could create a Spider-Man game where player choice actually matters, where you could approach situations as either Peter Parker or Spider-Man, with meaningful consequences for each choice.

The Bottom Line

I’m not saying Insomniac’s Spider-Man games are bad – they’re objectively fantastic. But “fantastic” and “the only way to do things” aren’t the same thing. Spider-Man as a character is big enough, complex enough, and beloved enough to support multiple interpretations from different creative teams.

Maybe it’s time we stopped asking “When is Spider-Man 3 coming?” and started asking “Who else could make an amazing Spider-Man game?” Because honestly, with budgets reaching astronomical levels and creative formulas becoming increasingly predictable, a fresh perspective might be exactly what everyone’s favorite web-head needs.

The gaming industry thrives on variety and innovation. Let’s give another studio the chance to show us what their vision of Spider-Man looks like. Who knows? We might just discover that there’s more than one amazing way to be your friendly neighborhood Spider-Man.

Visit Total Apex Gaming for more game-related news.