Top Collectible Wrestlers of 2025

Props.com ranked the most collectible stars for every major sport. The most collectible star in any sport goes to Shohei Ohtani of MLB's Los Angeles Dodgers, who has 727,253 trading card listings on eBay. That's 58,000 more than the surprising second place ranking for Mike Trout of the Los Angeles Angels. Rounding out the top ten are names of present and past, with Aaron Judge, Ken Griffey Jr., Michael Jordan, Cal Ripken Jr., Nolan Ryan, Patrick Mahomes, LeBron James, and Ronald Acuna Jr.

So just how do wrestlers compare to the A-List sports stars? Wrestling icons pale in comparison, but it's still a big market, with the late Hulk Hogan topping the eBay collectible card listings with 26,307. The top 5 are:

It's no surprise that Hulk Hogan would come in first, with the Hulkster being the most famous wrestler who ever lived, and his unfortunate passing this year making his collectibles even more desired. With John Cena the biggest name of the moment, and the leader of the Cenation on his retirement tour, it's understandable that he would be right on Hogan's tail. The Rock and Roman Reigns make sense as well. The only shock of the top 5 is Alexa Bliss, who, although she is a popular superstar in her own right, isn't on the same level as the other four names.

Rising Stars And Diverse Names Are Highly Sought Out Collectibles

The rest of the Top 20 is made up of WWE superstars, with only Mercedes Mone at 12 and Sting at 18 being the only wrestlers who are making their names away from the wrestling giant. The eBay data shows that WWE is the most desired promotion for trading cards by far, but it also reveals that newer superstars, as well as many women, are highly desired among a fanbase that is quickly expanding.

Charlotte Flair just misses out on the Top 5, coming in at 6, ahead of The Undertaker. Three women round out the Top 10 in Bayley, Becky Lynch, and Asuka. Rhea Ripley, Liv Morgan, and Bianca Belair are high up there too, in the bottom part of the Top 20. Triple H comes in at the eleven spot, with other major men stars such as Seth Rollins, Randy Orton, AJ Styles, and The Miz in the Top 20. Every name mentioned is a major part of the business, but how long until the stars of AEW and NXT rise up the rankings as well?