Following a stretch of five consecutive wins, the New York Yankees have endured a frustrating stretch against their archrivals, the Boston Red Sox, suffering back to back defeats. The losses, which continue to highlight the team's struggles against top teams, have slipped the Yankees to 69-59 on the season, dropping them to third in the American League East.
During this slump, shortstop Anthony Volpe has struggled—plagued by a drastic offensive woes, a spate of mental and defensive miscues, and growing displeasure from fans. Volpe's production has dipped this year: so far, he has put up a .209 batting average with 18 home runs, 65 RBIs and 56 runs scored in 127 games.
Amid Volpe's inconsistencies, manager Aaron Boone made interesting remarks, alluding to what could be his fate on the team in the coming weeks.
Ahead of Saturday's home game against the Red Sox, Boone acknowledged in a team update that giving Volpe a day off could be in play soon. That’s a significant development, especially considering Volpe has been an every day player.
His offensive slide has been alarming: since August 2, he’s slumping to a .127 batting average, .179 on-base percentage, and .254 slugging percentage. Fans have even booed him following errors and strikeouts in recent games.
Aaron Boone was asked if he would consider giving Anthony Volpe a day off given his struggles at the plate: pic.twitter.com/Je79Kv7EBI
— Yankees Videos (@snyyankees) August 23, 2025
Boone’s remarks come amid increasing scrutiny. Despite ongoing struggles in the field—Volpe leads all American League shortstops in errors and ranks near the bottom in advanced metrics like Defensive Runs Saved—Boone has been consistent in his support.
Back in July, he called Volpe a “top shortstop” and has continued to express belief in his potential.
Providing him a mental and physical reset with a day off may be both a strategic move and a show of confidence in his ability to rebound.
The Yankees continue their showdown with Boston on Saturday, a game with increasing postseason ramifications. With just weeks left in the regular season, New York is fighting to tighten its grip on the AL Wild Card picture, standing just ahead of the Red Sox despite recent stumbles
A bench day for Volpe could shift the dynamic in the lineup and defense, hopefully bringing sharper focus to a team that has leaned too heavily on home runs. The Yankees remain a playoff-caliber roster, but smoothing out lapses—especially at shortstop—will be vital if they intend to turn their best promise into playoff success.
More must-reads:
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!