Yardbarker
Yardbarker
x
The 2019 MLB all-rookie team
Michael Owens/Getty Images

The 2019 MLB all-rookie team

Whether they premiered as blue-chip prospects or less-touted minor leaguers just trying to make a name for themselves, first-year big leaguers have provided an inordinate amount of intrigue this season. While some of the youngsters on this list are already well on their way to superstardom, some under-the-radar guys really found a way to break through and contribute to their teams as well.  Let's take a look at the Yardbarker 2019 MLB all-rookie team. 

Catcher, Will Smith, Los Angeles Dodgers 

Smith has shuttled between L.A. and Triple-A Oklahoma City four different times this season, but since his most recent promotion in late July he's emerged as the top option behind the plate for the National League's best team. In 157 at-bats, the Louisville product has launched 14 homers and driven in 37 runs, bringing yet another threat to a dangerous Dodgers offense. Defensively Smith's gunned down a quarter of would be base stealers, and it will be fascinating to see if he really does catch playoff games for this team over veterans Austin Barnes and Russell Martin. More interesting still will be what Los Angeles does behind the plate moving forward, as its best prospect, Keibert Ruiz, is also a catcher. 

First Base, Pete Alonso, New York Mets 

The Mets right-handed slugger represents the most obvious choice for this list. After breaking camp with the big club — service time be damned — all Alonso has done is deliver one of the most productive rookie seasons in MLB history. Participating in all but one of New York's games, the man nicknamed "The Polar Bear" has hit .264 while leading the majors with 50 homers and driving in 115 runs. He's already shattered the Amazins' single-season home run record, and while it would take a furious hot streak this week, he's got an outside chance to set the franchise RBI record as well. It's improbable but not impossible that the Mets will squeak into October as the NL's second wild card, and if they do, Alonso could even become a dark horse MVP candidate. 

Second Base, Keston Hiura, Milwaukee Brewers 

For a couple of years, Hiura was the one minor leaguer in the Brewers organization whom rival clubs coveted in trade discussions. Milwaukee deemed him untouchable pretty much from the moment they took him ninth overall in the 2017 draft, and his performance since becoming a regular in the Brew Crew's lineup this summer has shown why. In a shade under 300 at-bats, Hiura has hit .301 with 18 long balls and 47 RBI while also adding 21 doubles and scoring 48 runs. He's become an even more vital member of this offense since Milwaukee lost superstar Christian Yelich to a knee injury, and the Brewers hope the young phenom has a few more big moments in him as they continue to chase a postseason berth. 

Shortstop, Fernando Tatis Jr., San Diego Padres 

Tatis was the top-ranked prospect in the game prior to his promotion this season, and while his year was unfortunately cut short by injury, it became evident from Day 1 that he's going to be one of the brightest stars in this sport for a long time. In 84 games for the Padres, the 20-year-old hit .317 with 22 home runs and 53 RBI while swiping 16 bags and racking up 197 total bases in only 334 at-bats. It's scary for the other teams in the NL West to think what his numbers in just half a season project to over a full six months, and San Diego fans are certainly looking forward to what he can do next year and beyond. 

Third Base, Vladimir Guerrero Jr., Toronto Blue Jays 

Another — and the second straight on this list — son of a well-known former big leaguer, Guerrero seemingly debuted with even more immediate fanfare than the above-mentioned Tatis. While his rookie season got off to less of a dominant start, Guerrero has come on down the stretch, and he's one of several young players the Blue Jays are counting on to return Canada to baseball relevancy. After hitting just .249 before the All-Star break, the right-handed slugger has turned in a .303 average over the past two-plus months, and his 15 homers and 68 RBI as a rookie are nothing to sneeze at. The show Guerrero put on during the Home Run Derby will not be forgotten any time soon and provided a glimpse at the power potential he has. As he continues to mature, Toronto has no doubt he's going to become an absolute superstar just like his namesake.  

Left Field, Bryan Reynolds, Pittsburgh Pirates 

Outside of Pittsburgh, Reynolds is far from a household name, but he's quietly been one of the most productive all-around offensive players in the National League. In 132 games the 24-year-old has hit .318 —good for fourth in the NL — while accumulating 57 extra-base hits and reaching base at a strong .381 clip. Since being promoted in mid-April the switch-hitter has been a mainstay in the middle of the Pirates line-up, and while 2019 has obviously been disappointing for the Bucs, the club is hopeful Reynolds can team with first baseman Josh Bell to help form the core of this team's next contender. 

Center Field, Victor Robles, Washington Nationals 

The Nationals had been waiting for Robles to break through, and while injuries derailed him in both 2017 and 2018, this year has finally served as the youngster's coming out party. Playing in nearly every Nats game, the 22-year-old has hit 17 big flies and driven in 64 runs while hitting .255, stealing 26 bases and playing superb defense at a premium position. His emergence has helped alleviate some of the frustration of Bryce Harper's free agent departure last winter, and together with Juan Soto, Robles should give Washington a dynamic outfield duo for years to come.  

Right Field, Aristides Aquino, Cincinnati Reds 

Aquino's presence on this list is sure to frustrate fans in the Bay Area who would instead have liked to see Mike Yastrzemski, but what this young man has been able to do since being promoted on Aug. 1 is too hard to ignore. In only 181 at-bats, Aquino has crushed 17 homers and racked up 44 RBI while delivering a .260 batting average and slugging .575. The right-handed hitter did not hit for this much power in AAA this season, but the Reds are certainly enjoying the ride, and they're hopeful he can ultimately become a building block for them moving forward. 

Designated Hitter, Eloy Jimenez, Chicago White Sox 

Jimenez has primarily played the outfield for the White Sox this season, but for the sake of our rookie team we're going to need to slide him in at DH. In 453 big league at-bats this season, the long-heralded prospect has hit .269 with 30 homers and 77 RBI while adding 17 doubles and becoming every bit of the right-handed power threat Chicago had long foreseen him developing into. The White Sox are still a little ways from competing in the AL Central, but their young core is finally starting to take shape, and it shouldn't surprise you if Jimenez helps lead this club back to the postseason in the somewhat near future. 


Getty Images

Rotation

Chris Paddack, San Diego Padres

A dominant spring training earned the fiery right-hander a spot in San Diego's opening day rotation, and he took the opportunity and ran with it. In 26 starts before being shut down due to an innings limit, the Austin, Texas, native turned in a 3.33 ERA with a 0.98 WHIP while punching out well over a batter/inning and holding the opposition to just a .204 batting average. Paddack has the stuff and attitude to be an elite starter at the game's highest level, and the Friars are envisioning him leading their staff for many years to come.

Mike Soroka, Atlanta Braves

If not for Pete Alonso in New York, Soroka would easily win National League Rookie of the Year. In 28 starts the Braves first-round pick from back in 2015 has gone 13-4 with a 2.60 ERA and a 1.09 WHIP. The Calgary native has quickly become the ace of a Braves team with serious postseason potential, and as of now he stands to start Game 1 of the NLDS for Atlanta. He's also placed himself firmly in the discussion for NL Cy Young, although you'd have to imagine he'll finish third in the voting behind LA's Hyun-Jin Ryu and the Mets Jacob deGrom.

Sandy Alcantara, Miami Marlins

Pitching in front of sparse crowds on a bad Marlins team doesn't exactly help garner a lot of national attention, but Alcantara's rookie season deserves recognition. In 30 starts the righty has worked to a 4.00 ERA with a 1.06 WHIP while holding opponents to a .234 average in 184.1 innings. Alcantara was the Marlins' lone All-Star representative this summer and has even thrown two complete game shutouts. His stuff is not overpowering by traditional measures, but he knows how to pitch, and Miami's hoping the prize from its Marcell Ozuna trade with St. Louis two winters ago can be a reliable member of its starting five for a long time.

Zach Plesac, Cleveland Indians

Plesac's emergence in 2019 is the primary reason the Indians rotation has been able to withstand all of the adversity that's been thrown its way in 2019. In 20 starts since his late May debut, the right-hander has turned in a 3.82 ERA in 110.2 frames while limiting the opposition to a .234 batting average and surrendering just a 1.22 WHIP. Cleveland is locked in a fierce three-teams-for-two-spots-wild-card race with Oakland and Tampa Bay and is hopeful Plesac has two more good starts in him between now and the closing bell.

Dakota Hudson, St. Louis Cardinals

Hudson gave the Redbirds 26 effective relief outings in 2018, but since moving to the rotation in spring training he's become one of the best starting pitchers in the NL. In 31 starts the righty from Mississippi State has won 16 games with a 3.45 ERA in 169.2 innings, and he's played an integral part in St. Louis' late-season surge to the top of the NL Central standings. Hudson's most important outings will have to wait for October, but the Cardinals are confident he'll be up for the task.

Bullpen

Giovanny Gallegos, St. Louis Cardinals

The Cardinals were absolutely killed for their 2018 midseason trade that sent Luke Voit to the Yankees, and they watched him go on to become a folk hero in New York. But the deal doesn't look quite so one-sided now. Gallegos was the main piece St. Louis brought back, and the right-hander has become an absolute dominant member of its relief corps. In 62 outings he's worked to a tremendous 2.31 ERA with an even better 0.80 WHIP. Opponents are hitting just .167 against Gallegos, and he's struck out an eye-opening 93 hitters in 70 innings. The Mexico native has quickly become an integral piece of St. Louis' late-inning equation, and the Redbirds are counting on him to continue dominating down the stretch and into October.

Nick Anderson, Tampa Bay Rays

Anderson began this season in Miami and only arrived in Tampa Bay at the trade deadline, and while he was good for the Marlins, he's been even better as a Ray. In 63.2 total innings split between his two Florida stops, the Mayville State product has struck out an incredible 107 hitters while turning in a 1.08 WHIP and a 3.39 ERA. The Rays are locked in a heated race for a playoff spot right now, making every game imperative, and Anderson has responded to the added pressure.

Josh Taylor, Boston Red Sox 

The struggles of the Red Sox bullpen have been much discussed this season, but Taylor simply doesn't help that narrative. In 51 games the southpaw has impressed, turning in a 3.06 ERA in 47 innings and striking out a dominant 11.87/9. Lefties are hitting only .209 against Taylor, and he's put himself in position to be his team's primary left-handed setup man coming out of spring training in 2020.



Getty Images

Manager

Rocco Baldelli, Minnesota Twins

Baldelli was a somewhat interesting hire this past winter, as at almost 38 years old he's actually younger than quite a few players in the game. Fast forward a few months, and the Twins are certainly thrilled with their decision. Baldelli has this team a year ahead of where most expected it to be, and as the Twins close in on their first division title in nine years, he's certainly deserving of the AL Manager of the Year Award that he will surely win. An ALDS matchup with either the Yankees or Astros will be no picnic, but Baldelli's squad is extremely likable and certainly won't be an easy out in October.

Justin Mears

Justin Mears is a freelance sports writer from Long Beach Island, NJ. Enjoys being frustrated by the Mets and Cowboys, reading Linwood Barclay novels, and being yelled at by his toddler son. Follow him on twitter @justinwmears

More must-reads:

Customize Your Newsletter

Yardbarker +

Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!

TODAY'S BEST

Twins' Rocco Baldelli Announces Carlos Correa Update After Leaving Red Sox Game
MLB

Twins' Rocco Baldelli Announces Carlos Correa Update After Leaving Red Sox Game

Shortstop Carlos Correa is in his fourth season with the Minnesota Twins after debuting in the majors with the Houston Astros in 2015. The former first overall pick in the 2012 MLB Draft lived up to expectations early, winning AL Rookie of the Year in his first full season. Over seven seasons in Houston, he earned two All-Star selections, a Gold Glove award, and helped the Astros capture two World Series titles. Correa joined Minnesota in free agency prior to the 2022 season, and made his third career All-Star appearance last year—his first with the Twins. However, a flare-up of plantar fasciitis in his right foot sidelined him for nearly the entire second half. He still finished 2024 with a strong stat line, hitting .310 with a .905 OPS and 14 home runs over 86 games. During Tuesday’s game against the Boston Red Sox, Correa was removed from the game in the second inning and replaced with Brooks Lee. Manager Rocco Baldelli provided an update during the game, “Carlos was a little lightheaded out there and it didn't go away so we're going to get him out of the game.” This season, Correa has yet to regain the offensive form he showed last year. Through 92 games, he’s batting .265 with a career-low .701 OPS and has hit just seven home runs. His struggles have contributed to Minnesota’s disappointing 51–55 record, and the team now looks poised to be sellers at the trade deadline on Thursday.

NFL analyst says teams should be 'extremely scared' of this franchise in 2025
NFL

NFL analyst says teams should be 'extremely scared' of this franchise in 2025

While the Philadelphia Eagles, Detroit Lions and Washington Commanders have garnered a lot of attention lately, there is one NFC team that has quietly been flying under the radar. The Tampa Bay Buccaneers lost a one-score game to the Lions in the divisional round in 2023 and followed that up with another one-score loss to QB Jayden Daniels and the Commanders last season, proving how close they have been to the ultimate prize in the two seasons with Baker Mayfield under center. In an appearance on ESPN's "Get Up" Tuesday morning, analyst and former player Ryan Clark offered high praise for Mayfield and what the Buccaneers are capable of. "Baker Mayfield is a top-10 quarterback in this league," Clark said. "Baker Mayfield is a football player. And when I say that, I know people at home are gonna be like, 'Duh, he gets paid to play football.' No, not all quarterbacks are seen as football players. Not all quarterbacks are embraced in the locker room as one of us." Clark sees the Buccaneers as a team the rest of the league should be paying attention to because of who they have returning and the close calls in the playoffs the last two seasons. "This is a team that's been on the cusp the last two years," Clark said. "Now you think about some of the pieces they've added, the confidence in their quarterback and the way that he plays, and Todd Bowles with another year to understand winning at a high level at the head coach position. This is a team you better be extremely scared of because they're stacked and they're confident." Mayfield has been sensational during his time with the Buccaneers. Although he did throw 16 interceptions, Mayfield accounted for the third-most passing yards (4,500) in the league last season and has thrown the most TD passes (69) in the last two seasons, per StatMuse. To add even more incentive for Mayfield, the team restructured his contract, which is set to expire after the 2026 season, to include $30M in guaranteed salary for that season. The Buccaneers return a lot of production on both sides of the ball, in addition to bringing in first-round draft pick Emeka Egbuka, who topped 1,000 receiving yards twice at Ohio State and accounted for 26 total TDs. While Tampa Bay allowed the 17th-most points per game (22.7) last season, it returns the majority of its defensive production. On top of that, the offseason acquisition of veteran LB and two-time Pro-Bowler Haason Reddick, who agreed to terms on a one-year deal, should be a welcomed addition for a franchise that had some question marks on defense last season. The Buccaneers are projected to have the sixth-easiest schedule in the NFL this season and have the best chance to win the NFC South for the fifth consecutive season, according to ESPN Analytics. If Mayfield can cut back on his turnovers and the defense can create more pressure on opposing QBs, the Buccaneers could be a threat in the NFC once again as they look to put their recent nail-biting losses in the postseason behind them.

Paul Finebaum Hints At Premier College Football Coach Being Fired with Poor Season
College Football

Paul Finebaum Hints At Premier College Football Coach Being Fired with Poor Season

The 2025 college football season presents significant pressure for top coaches. Another disappointing season could result in them seeking new jobs. One of the coaches in question is Brent Venables, who is the head coach of the Oklahoma Sooners. He is entering his fourth season in this position. However, in two of his first three seasons, Venables' team has ended with a losing record, a situation that hadn’t occurred for more than 20 years before he took over. The Sooners are coming off a 6-7 season last year; however, there is some optimism for this season as they have added former Washington State Cougars quarterback John Mateer and former California Golden Bears running back Jaydn Ott to their roster. Last season, Mateer threw for 3,139 yards, 29 touchdowns and only seven interceptions, while also rushing for 826 yards and scoring 15 touchdowns. Although Ott faced challenges with injuries during the 2024 season, he had an impressive performance in 2023, rushing for 1,315 yards and scoring 12 touchdowns. On "The Paul Finebaum Show," SEC Network analyst Paul Finebaum stated that the Sooners need to start the season with a 5-0 record before facing Texas in the Cotton Bowl. Following that game, he believes they are likely to lose to Texas and will then need to secure a 4-2 record to finish the year. If they don't, he could be looking for a new job. "If they can win all but maybe two of those games, I think that Brent Venables may have a great record and will likely be around for a while," Finebaum said. "Otherwise, I think you know the answer to the question." If the Sooners decide to part ways with Venables, it would come with a hefty price tag. Venables' buyout is $34.9 million following this season. This speculation from Finebaum arises just one year after Venables agreed to a significant contract extension. Venables signed a six-year contract after the 2023 season, which the Oklahoma Board of Regents approved in June 2024. The deal guarantees him an annual salary of over $8.5 million for its entire duration. He originally signed a six-year, $43.5 million contract with the Sooners in December 2021. Venables' contract is fully guaranteed, and after this season, his buyout will decrease by nearly $10 million each year until the end of the contract. The Sooners are hopeful that Venables’ team can bounce back this season and avoid the need to search for a new coach in the upcoming offseason. Oklahoma is scheduled to open the season at 6 p.m. ET on Aug. 30 against the Illinois State Redbirds.

Commanders reportedly hesitant about one issue with Terry McLaurin deal
NFL

Commanders reportedly hesitant about one issue with Terry McLaurin deal

The 2024 offseason expanded the $30M-per-year wide receiver club to six members. D.K. Metcalf, Ja’Marr Chase and Garrett Wilson have taken it to nine this year. Terry McLaurin is undoubtedly pushing to bump that number to 10, after seeing 2019 Day 2 classmates Metcalf and A.J. Brown land among that contingent. McLaurin reported to training camp Sunday and landed on the active/PUP list. As our Rory Parks explained, skepticism exists about how injured the Commanders’ top wide receiver really is. An ankle injury has keyed the PUP stay, but it can be safely assumed McLaurin would be ready to practice if an extension comes to pass. Nevertheless, the Commanders have been surprised by the difficulty of these talks. Using an injury to avoid practicing while negotiating — developments the Jonathan Taylor and Micah Parsons sagas brought — represents a third tactic, joining the holdout and the increasingly utilized hold-in amid extension talks. McLaurin shifted from a holdout to the injury route; no matter how he is accomplishing not practicing, the seventh-year veteran is aiming to land a lucrative third contract. His age provides a complication for Washington. McLaurin is going into an age-30 season, separating him from Brown and Metcalf. Both Ole Miss products were drafted just before McLaurin, a 2019 third-round pick, but they are each two years younger. This strengthened their cases for big-ticket third contracts. McLaurin went first to ignite the second-tier boom on the receiver market in 2022, agreeing to a three-year, $69.6M extension. That shaped the Metcalf and Deebo Samuel extensions, both of which coming in higher than McLaurin’s despite the latter’s consistency with suboptimal quarterback situations. McLaurin’s AAV has dropped to 17th at wide receiver. The Commanders are prepared to extend their top wideout, but Sportskeeda.com’s Tony Pauline indicates the "holdup" is regarding the $30M-AAV number. Some around the league point to the team not wanting to go into that neighborhood for McLaurin, despite his five 1,000-yard seasons. Courtland Sutton and McLaurin are nearly the same age, and the Broncos’ top target signed a four-year, $92M extension. That matches where the Titans went for Calvin Ridley (now 30) in 2024. McLaurin, though, has a better resume than both and should be aiming higher. The Commanders have a Jayden Daniels rookie contract to structure another McLaurin extension around as well. Adam Peters was around for the 49ers’ 2022 Samuel extension but not Brandon Aiyuk‘s $30M-per-year deal. (The Samuel extension also did not work out for the 49ers, who proceeded with a salary dump of sorts by trading him to the Commanders.) The second-year GM taking a hardline stance with McLaurin would be an interesting route given the WR’s importance to a sudden contender. Peters confirmed talks are ongoing, with that comment coming after McLaurin expressed frustration about the negotiations. A potential gap between the pack of 20-somethings (and Tyreek Hill) north of $30M AAV and the Tee Higgins–Jaylen Waddle–D.J. Moore tier could be relevant here, and it will be interesting to see if McLaurin settles for something just south of that $30MM benchmark. Guarantees and contract structure, of course, will be important to determining the value as well. A short-term extension should be reached soon, per Pauline, but if the Commanders hold the line at or around $30M, the McLaurin matter could drag on for a while longer.