x
Blue Jays free agent target: George Springer
Nick Turchiaro-Imagn Images

September 27th, 2026, a day that Toronto Blue Jays fans believed was George Springer’s final game in a Blue Jays uniform. After he recorded a base hit in his second at-bat of the game, Springer was removed from the game by manager John Schneider and replaced by Sean Keys. What followed was an emotional Springer leaving the field with cheers aplenty from fans and embraces from his teammates. With 2027 being uncertain about how baseball will return to play, it begs the question of whether that will be the last game Springer plays in the big leagues, let alone in Toronto.

Springer, 37, is coming off a down season in 2026, as he only hit 15 home runs and 54 RBIs in 126 games. While it’s hard to repeat the numbers he put up in 2025, which were his best since 2019, Springer had a lot of injury troubles, such as the broken toe he sustained back in April. Springer’s wRC+ stat was only 105 this past season, which ranked sixth on the team overall.

Injuries did Springer in big time in 2026, and at 37 years old, it is a lot to shoulder, especially if you aspire to be an everyday player in the big leagues. Now, even though the front office may be looking to part ways with their everyday designated hitter after the past three seasons, sometimes fate brings you back together. Now granted, Springer is not going to be the team’s everyday DH going forward on paper, although his bat and presence are vastly important to a team looking to go back to contention.

While many believe the DH spot belongs to Anthony Santander this coming season (whenever it happens), it is never truly written in stone especially, given the health issues of Santander making him miss all of the 2026 season. Having a 37-year-old veteran on the bench is not ideal for a team wanting to have flexibility, he can still very much hit at the major-league level. In the second half, Springer hit .288/.344/.444 in 60 games, a huge uptick from his .218/.303/.374 in his first 66 games.

When the Blue Jays had their big surge for a wild card spot in July, Springer was hitting .290 with an OPS of .878. Springer even saw an uptick in production when he was moved out of the leadoff spot in favor of batting fourth in the cleanup spot. Springer hit .282 versus his .222 batting first.

With runners in scoring position this past season, Springer was able to hit .248 and drive in 38 runs, good enough for fourth on the team.

Let’s first start by acknowledging that, likely, Springer has played his final game as a Blue Jay. With how the send-off went in game 162, it almost feels too perfect to go back on. However, if there’s a fit that the front office sees, they will absolutely welcome him back for at least one more season.

This could potentially be very similar to the Blue Jays bringing back José Bautista in 2017. Many wrote off that Bautista was ever going to play for the team again, and he signed a one-year, $18-million contract to return. While the fit was clearly no longer there in that scenario, perhaps Springer could be back in a limited role. If there is a return, I do see the Blue Jays leaning toward a similar deal that Max Scherzer got this past season: a one-year contract with performance bonuses and clauses to be a higher value.

This article first appeared on Bluejaysnation and was syndicated with permission.

More must-reads:

Customize Your Newsletter

Yardbarker +

Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!