
The Cardinals will not tender infielder Nolan Gorman a contract before the 4 p.m. CT deadline on Friday, Joel Sherman of the New York Post reports. Gorman will hit free agency once the move becomes official.
Although the Cardinals could have controlled Gorman via arbitration through 2028, they will move on early after his production nosedived over the past three years. MLBTR contributor Matt Swartz projected a $3.4MM salary in 2027 for Gorman, but the Cardinals deemed it too rich for a player they demoted to the minors for a large chunk of last season. With Gorman’s stock down, the Cardinals came up short in their attempts to find a trade partner for the 26-year-old.
Gorman’s tenure with the Cardinals will come to an end eight years after they chose him 19th overall in the 2018 draft. Thanks in part to his prodigious power, Gorman was considered a top-end prospect when he debuted in St. Louis in May 2022. There were questions about Gorman’s high strikeout totals then, though, and the lefty hitter has done nothing to allay those concerns since. In 1,883 plate appearances with the Cardinals, Gorman logged a 33.8% strikeout rate. Only six qualified hitters have fared worse in that category since 2022. While Gorman has drawn walks at a respectable 10.4% clip in the bigs, it hasn’t been enough to overcome his swing-and-miss issues. He’ll leave St. Louis with a below-average .212/.295/.402 line (94 wRC+) and 83 home runs.
Gorman looked like a legitimate building block for the Cardinals as recently as 2023. Despite a 31.9% strikeout rate, he slashed .236/.328/.476 (118 wRC+) and swatted 27 homers in 464 plate appearances. That production was not a sign of things to come, however. Since 2024, he has hit an unplayable .199/.280/.365 with an 80 wRC+ in 1,106 trips to the plate in the majors. Hoping to revive Gorman, the Cardinals sent him to Triple-A Memphis last June. But in two and a half months there, he hit .182 and fanned at a disastrous 36.3% clip. After the Cardinals recalled him in August, he went just 10 of 65 with 24 strikeouts, eight walks and two homers in 23 games.
Gorman has picked up most of his defensive work at second base, where he began his career. He has never drawn plus marks at the keystone, however, having accounted for minus-18 Outs Above Average, minus-12 Defensive Runs Saved and minus-12 Fielding Run Value apiece. With young star JJ Wetherholt taking over at second for the Cardinals in 2026, Gorman made all 68 of his defensive appearances in the infield corners. Sixty-six of those came at third, where he was credited with 2 Defensive Runs Saved. He earned neutral OAA and FRV grades.
Four years after debuting with the Cardinals as a touted prospect, Gorman will head to the open market as a reclamation project. While no one was willing to give up anything for Gorman in a trade, teams in need of an infielder/DH type could consider taking a cheap flier on him in free agency.
More must-reads:
+
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!