x
Giancarlo Stanton Causing Yankees Major Lineup Problem
Wendell Cruz/Imagn Images

On Nov. 10, general manager Brian Cashman revealed that Giancarlo Stanton would be back with the New York Yankees in spring training, saying, "He's not going anywhere."

While the Yankees expect Stanton back, his return is actually causing quite a few problems. Stanton cannot play in the field, meaning he is locked into the designated hitter spot. That is causing problems for Luis García Jr. and Aaron Judge.

Last season, Stanton missed most of the year, and García played first base and Ben Rice played designated hitter. With Stanton back, Rice will go back to first base, meaning García will have to go back to playing second base, as he did for his entire career before last season.

It would be really easy for the Yankees to just plug García in at second base if it were not for Anthony Volpe. Volpe looked good after his return from being demoted, and he figures to be part of the equation at second base.

Ultimately, Stanton's return to the team has a ripple effect that essentially takes at-bats away from García. The only way around it is seemingly moving on from Volpe and giving García the keys to second base. Another option would be to move Volpe to third base full-time and move on from Ryan McMahon.

However, as long as McMahon is on the team, the Yankees cannot commit to that plan. However, even if the Yankees were to do that, it's not really an upgrade at third base unless Volpe proves he can actually be a consistent offensive force. Going into the year, having to rely on that is not great.

On top of all of that, the Yankees are reportedly exploring the third base market. If they do add an external third baseman to replace McMahon, then they are really in a bind with García's playing time.

The easiest solution for the Yankees would be to move on from Stanton, play Rice at designated hitter, play García at first base, play Volpe at second base and then add a real upgrade at third base.

Another ramification of Stanton's return is Aaron Judge's health. He missed most of last season, and he is not getting any younger. The Yankees may prefer to get him off his feet to help keep him healthy, but they cannot do that with Stanton clogging the designated hitter spot.

This article first appeared on Baseball Now and was syndicated with permission.

More must-reads:

Customize Your Newsletter

Yardbarker +

Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!