
It doesn't take much for the San Francisco Giants to fall apart in 2026. On Wednesday in Kansas City, it took an unreviewable call and an ejection for a 3-0 lead to disappear.
Giants manager Tony Vitello got ejected arguing the call when Vinnie Pasquantino overslid second base on a double, only for second base umpire Mike Estabrook to rule the play a push and thus unreviewable. The Kansas City Royals followed with a five-run inning on their way to a 5-4 win.
When Estabrook ruled Pasquantino safe, he also declared that shortstop Willy Adames had pushed the Royals first baseman off the bag. However, Adames merely tagged him when Pasquantino may have been off the base, with no pushing involved. Vitello argued intensely, eventually getting tossed for the length and intensity of his protest.
It didn't look like Pasquantino was truly out when Adames tagged him anyway, but the lengthy pause where all parties debated the issue seemed to throw starter Landen Roupp, who'd given up only three hits and no runs, off his game. Two pitches later, Salvador Perez had homered to make the game 3-2, and two relievers later, the Royals had a 5-3 lead.
Tony Vitello got ejected after arguing one of the worst calls you'll see all year pic.twitter.com/nnsFzJI5Sa
— SF Giants on NBCS (@NBCSGiants) July 22, 2026
It's not that Vitello was wrong in wanting to challenge the close play at second. The problem is he wasn't picking his battles. He managed to get thrown out of the game and waste time without truly getting his money's worth with the intensity of his argument, nor gaining any advantage for his team.
Vitello has been a mix of brash and cautious in his first season with the Giants after previous coaching at the University of Tennessee. He's drawn three ejections for arguing, but hesitates to use pinch-hitters early or steal bases. The Giants are above average in OPS and eighth in the majors in slugging, but they've scored fewer runs than all but three teams.
That may be due to the team's struggles to deal with adversity, like when trailing in late innings or when an inning threatens to spiral out of control, like the seventh inning on Wednesday. Ultimately, that's on the manager. Based on the latest game, the Giants' fifth straight loss, Vitello isn't even ready to argue at a big-league level.
More must-reads:
+
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!