x
Is Cam Schlittler the Yankees New Ace?
Sep 29, 2026; Bronx, New York, USA; New York Yankees starting pitcher Cam Schlittler (31) pitches against the Boston Red Sox during the first inning of game one of the Wildcard round of the 2026 MLB Playoffs at Yankee Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Brad Penner-Imagn Images

Gerrit Cole is back. Max Fried is here. But when the Yankees needed one guy to start October, they turned to a 25-year-old from Walpole, Massachusetts. The unexpected rise of Cam Schlittler has captured fans’ attention this season.

Let’s not overthink this.

On Sept. 29, the Yankees faced their rivals, the Boston Red Sox, in the Wild Card Series. Game 1 in the Bronx, Aaron Boone had to choose his starter. He had former Cy Young winner Gerrit Cole. He had Max Fried, but he chose Schlittler, and Schlittler showed up.  

Let’s rewind to February. The headline in Tampa wasn’t about Schlittler’s velocity. It was about his back. Inflammation and a lat issue kept him off the mound for weeks; he fell behind in camp, and with Cole still in rehab from Tommy John and Carlos Rodon on the shelf, the ‘Yankees’ rotation suddenly looked thin. Then came the games. 

On March 27 in San Francisco, 5 1/3 innings, surrendered just one hit, and recorded eight strikeouts. Five days later, hosting Seattle, another 6 1/3 scoreless frames. His back wasn’t an issue. Opposing lineups certainly were.

Through 16 starts on the bump, he had built an 8-3 record alongside a 1.71 ERA. 

The lowest by a Yankee that deep into the season since Whitey Ford in 1964. On June 19th, he had a career-high 13 strikeouts against the Reds over six scoreless innings at the Stadium. Knicks Guard Josh Heart declared that the Cy Young race was over. In June. He made the All-Star team and was lined up to start in the Midsummer Classic. He passed, choosing to stay on his normal schedule. The Yankees were already thinking about October. 

The Resume

The Final line: 14-6, 1.95 ERA, 239 Strikeouts, 0.92 WHIP in 193 ⅔ innings. Here’s why that’s more than a great season. 

  • 1.95 ERA: Best in the American League, and the lowest by a Yankee since Ron Guidry’s 1.74 in 1978. Only Spud Chandler (1.64 in 1943) and Guidry have done better among qualified Yankees
  • 239 strikeouts: Tied Jack Chesbro (1904) for the fourth most in a single season in franchise history.
  •  21 starts allowing one run or fewer: The most in baseball
  • 6.2 fWAR and a .244 opponent OBP: Both tops in the AL 

And then there’s the road. Some pitchers rely on the home crowd for help, but Schlittler thrives on “boos”. Away from the Bronx, he went 8-2 with a 1.16 ERA in 17 starts, holding hitters to a .153 average. Simply great. Those numbers were the best of any pitcher in baseball. This earned him the 2026 Players Choice Awards AL Outstanding Pitcher. 

The pitches 

It starts with a four-seamer that lives around 98 mph and comes downhill from a 6-foot-6 frame. This year, he relied on it approximately 44% of the time. Hitters are aware it’s on its way. It is of no significance. What distinguishes him as an ace rather than merely a hard thrower is the surrounding elements: three varied fastball types and a curveball that transitioned from a demonstration pitch to a strikeout tool by the conclusion of the season.

Keep in mind, this was not meant to occur. Schlittler was selected in the seventh round from Northeastern in 2022, signed for $205,000, and did not appear on any top-100 prospect list. He started 2025 in Double-A and was promoted in July only because of Clarke Schmidt‘s injury. A year and a half later, he’s the top pitcher in the American League.

Boston’s Worst Nightmare

The last fanbase you want to ask about Schlittler is the Boston Red Sox. Last October, after Red Sox fans came after him and his family online, he answered with eight scoreless innings, 12 strikeouts and zero walks in an elimination game.

This year? Same movie, different date. In Game 1 of the Wild Card Series, he struck out the side in the first and went 6 1/3 scoreless with 10 strikeouts, two hits and one walk on a career-high 117 pitches. He threw 32 curveballs, and Boston couldn’t touch them whatsoever. The game ended with the Yankees 9, Boston 0. It made him the first-ever Yankee with two scoreless, double-digit strikeout playoff starts.

His Career ERA against Boston, postseason included, was 0.47. 

Schlittler said, “If you want to be a legend, which is obviously the goal, you have to do it in the postseason.” 

The Painful Part

This is the part that stings. The Yankees ran into the 98-64 Tampa Bay Rays. With the team down 1-0 in the ALDS, Schlittler took the ball in Game 2 at Tropicana Field and lasted just 4 1/3 innings, charged with four runs as the defense behind him committed four errors. The game ended with the Rays winning 5-2. Tampa finished the sweep two days later. Schlittler didn’t blame anyone but himself.

The Verdict?

So is Schlittler the new Yankee Ace? 

Cole will have something to say about that in 2027. He’s still Gerrit Cole. But aces aren’t defined by contracts or résumés. They’re defined by who gets the ball when the season is on the line. In 2026, that was Schlittler, and it wasn’t close.

On Wednesday, he won the Cy Young Award, and he already has the Players’ Choice Award for AL Outstanding Pitcher. Now the question isn’t whether Cam Schlittler is the guy; it’s how long he can keep these performances up. 

This article first appeared on The Lead and was syndicated with permission.

More must-reads:

Customize Your Newsletter

Yardbarker +

Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!