Is It Time To Trade Guardians Designated Hitter Franmil Reyes

Positives

Lineup Versatility

If the Guardians traded Franmil Reyes, it would make the lineup much more versatile. For example, they could move Josh Naylor to the primary designated hitter and play Owen Miller at first base full time. This would open up either second base or shortstop (depending on where you want to play Andres Gimenez) for one of the Guardians’ young prospects in Tyler Freeman or Gabriel Arias.

If neither of those prospects are ready to be brought up full-time, then Tito could at least shift Amed Rosario back to the infield. This would open up a spot in the outfield for possibly Richie Palacios to get called back up and get more playing time.

More Production From DH

I have already gone through Franmil’s season stats, they aren’t great. Trading Reyes and plugging in almost anyone else at designated hitter would provide more offensive production. Whether that be Josh Naylor, Owen Miller, or anyone else. 

Negatives 

Lack Of Power In Lineup

Even with Reyes in the lineup, the Guardians already lack power outside of Josh Naylor and Jose Ramirez. This season, Reyes still ranks in the 98th percentile of average exit velocity, 94th percentile of hard hit percentage, and 93rd percentile of barrel percentage. 

Trading Reyes would leave a massive hole in the batting order that would need to be filled. Unless the Guardians were to get a power bat in return for Reyes, which is unlikely, this would be hard to fill with the existing roster.

All Just One Bad Slump

This could all just be one massive slump, and Franmil could break out of it at any moment. We have all seen what Franmil is capable of when he is locked in. During his six-game hit streak in early May, Franmil hit .524 with a 1.279 OPS. 

When Franmil is hitting well, he is one of the Guardians' best hitters. Trading him only to see him immediately get hot again would be tough to watch as a fan.