New York Mets love Brendan Donovan

Donovan, 28, is coming off of a strong 2025 campaign where he slashed .287/.353/.422 in 118 games and earned his first All-Star selection. While starting 91 games at second base, the versatile fielder also made appearances in left field (18) and shortstop (6). Across his four-year MLB career, Donovan has logged over 100 innings at each position on the field except for center field.

While he is an above average defender at many positions, much of Donovan's tremendous value comes from his consistent offense output. He is a career .282 hitter that holds up well against lefty pitching (.249). Donovan has become a leader and an important piece of the Cardinals clubhouse but can immediately impact winning on a more competitive club if he is traded.

For the Mets, Donovan would likely figure in as a Jeff McNeil replacement. McNeil, while coming off a strong season, has been reported as a potential trade candidate alongside Brandon Nimmo. Donovan could also be seen as a Nimmo replacement if a deal is made there but would likely see time in both the infield and outfield regardless of other moves.

With a consistent bat, versatile glove, and veteran presence, Donovan could be the perfect piece to elevate a Mets lineup that is at a crossroads between leaning into their young talent and relying on their aging vets. While it appears that Donovan is generating interest from a large portion of the league, New York has the minor league capital to propose an attractive package to St. Louis. As rumors continue to swirl around the selling franchise, expect the Mets to emerge as top buyers.