x
Padres, Gavin Sheets Agree To Three-Year Deal
IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

The Padres and first baseman Gavin Sheets have agreed to a three-year, $11MM contract, reports Robert Murray of FanSided. ESPN’s Jeff Passan adds that Sheets will get a $500K signing bonus and $2.5MM salary for the upcoming season. The 2028 and 2029 seasons are player options valued at $4MM apiece.

Sheets, a client of Covenant Sports Group, was projected by MLBTR contributor Matt Swartz to receive a $6.5MM salary in his final trip through arbitration. This new arrangement guarantees him some extra money while also providing multiple chances to test free agency if he performs at a high level.

The extension is a three-year deal in name only. If Sheets performs well this coming season, he’ll almost certainly opt out and test free agency in search of a larger deal. Presumably, there’s a buyout on the player options that’d further boost Sheets’ earnings if he takes one of his opt-out opportunities. The deal spares the Padres on Sheets’ luxury tax hit by presenting a somewhat artificially low annual value while affording both player and team some protection in the event that Sheets suffers an injury or simply performs poorly this coming season.

Sheets, 31 in April, originally signed with the Friars on a minor league deal ahead of the 2025 season. He made the club that year and rebounded from a poor 2023-24 run with the ChiSox, hitting .252/.317/.429 with a career-high 19 home runs for San Diego. His 2026 showing wasn’t as strong, but Sheets was hobbled by a foot injury in the second half. He batted .236/.326/.461 (121 wRC+) into early July in a sample of 288 plate appearances, walking at a strong 10.8% clip against a 22.6% strikeout rate.

Sheets (perhaps literally) limped to a .156/.282/.248 finish across his final 131 trips to the plate. He tallied one plate appearance during the Wild Card series but made it count, punching a two-run, pinch-hit, go-ahead home run deep into the right field seats against a 101 mph heater off Cubs righty Daniel Palencia. Sheets went hitless in three plate appearances against the Brewers during the National League Division Series.

It’s been a decent two years in San Diego for Sheets, who’s combined for a .235/.315/.415 line (107 wRC+) while calling the Gaslamp Quarter home. He’s a player with both platoon and defensive limitations. Sheets has tagged righties for a .237/.326/.445 batting line with 34 homers in 740 plate appearances since signing in San Diego. He’s been brutal against southpaws, hitting just .228/.281/.320 in 224 tries. With the glove, Sheets has seen time at first base and in the outfield corners but has graded poorly at all three spots.

We’ll see how the balance of the Padres’ offseason plays out, but as things stand, Sheets is in position to see frequent playing time against right-handed pitching. The Padres don’t have clear answers at first base, designated hitter or in left field. Sheets can be part of the solution at any of the three spots, depending on what additions president of baseball operations A.J. Preller has in store for his club.

At the end of the 2027 season, Sheets will be choosing between free agency and remaining two-year, $8MM commitment. The net sum of his decision would be lower, of course, if there’s a buyout on his 2028 player option. It seemingly sets the stage for him to opt out, but platoon corner bats with sub-par gloves is not a skill set that’s particularly en vogue among modern front offices. (The Twins, for instance, just non-tendered Trevor Larnach rather than pay a projected $6.3MM salary, though Larnach is coming off wrist surgery.) His long-term outlook in San Diego is firmly tied to his 2027 performance, but today’s deal ensures that Sheets will play a notable role in San Diego’s 2027 quest to return to postseason baseball.

This article first appeared on MLB Trade Rumors and was syndicated with permission.

More must-reads:

Customize Your Newsletter

Yardbarker +

Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!