Pittsburgh Pirates centerfielder Oneil Cruz has been in a terrible month-long slump that has tanked his season numbers and severely limited an already-bad offense. Even worse, he has had a couple of plays over the past week that just looked bad from an effort standpoint.
One of those happened late in Tuesday's 9-3 loss to the Milwaukee Brewers when he did not run hard on a double-play ball.
That resulted in manager Don Kelly removing him from the game.
When asked about it after the game Kelly said it was about "energy and effort," and he would not commit to him starting Wednesday afternoon's game. He acknowledged Cruz is working hard to get out of his slump and that he was made aware of what the expectation for effort is, but that he simply fell short in this instance.
Pirates manager Don Kelly said Oneil Cruz was removed from tonight’s game due to “energy and effort” on the double play he hit into in his final at-bat. He was unwilling to say if Cruz will be in the lineup tomorrow.
— Noah Hiles (@_NoahHiles) June 25, 2025
Cruz was accepting of the decision and said it can be a learning experience and teaching moment.
Oneil Cruz's on what he can learn from being benched tonight:
— Noah Hiles (@_NoahHiles) June 25, 2025
"I accepted it really well, just because we have two guys here, [Andrew] McCutchen and Tommy Pham, who are really good examples. They always run hard. They always go out there and give 100%. This is a teaching point…
Cruz is the Pirates' best and most dynamic offensive player, and through the first two months of the season, he looked to be on track for a breakout year. Along with leading the league in stolen bases, he was posting an on-base percentage well over .360, an OPS over .800 and flirting with a 40-home run, 40-stolen base pace.
But since the start of June, his numbers have completely tanked, while his strikeout rate has skyrocketed.
Cruz is a polarizing player in Pittsburgh because he hasn't really excelled in the field at shortstop or center field, and he has had some inconsistency at the plate and not always hit for the highest average. He has also had some fundamental mistakes at times in the field, especially as he has adjusted to center field.
But he is also an incredible talent who not only has the highest upside of any position player on the team, but he has also been a really productive hitter.
He is not playing like that right now, however, and it is impacting all phases of his game. After botching a ground ball in center field this past week, he did not run after it or make an effort to get it. He did not get benched or removed for that. The double-play ball Tuesday night was too much for Kelly to ignore. Maybe it is the wakeup call he needed to get his game back on track.
More must-reads:
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!