
On Wednesday, November 18, the Kansas City Royals and Seattle Mariners completed a six-player trade, with the big name involved being third baseman Maikel Garcia, who was sent to Seattle.
The complete deal features Garcia, L.P. Langevin, and James McArthur heading to Seattle in exchange for Logan Evans, Jose A. Ferrer, and Bryce Miller.
It’s a trade that I love for the Royals and hate for the Mariners, and I’ll explain why.
Garcia is a glove-first, bat-second third baseman with a hefty contract.
In MLB, if you play third base, you basically have to be a vacuum at the position, as it’s assumed you will be good defensively.
Garcia is above average at third base, having won a Gold Glove at the position in 2025, but his contract isn’t just paying for him to be good defensively; it’s also paying him to carry a big stick, and he doesn’t have one.
Garcia simply doesn’t have a powerful bat, as he hit only three home runs for the Royals last season, an injury-plagued 82-game season.
I’m sorry, but injuries or not, three home runs by a third baseman just isn’t going to cut it in MLB.
At age 26 and moving to the pitcher-friendly confines of T-Mobile Park in Seattle, I don’t think his hitting numbers will go up, either.
Garcia’s OPS+ of 102 in 2026 showed that Garcia was 2% above league average at third base, yet he’s being paid like he’s a top hitter.
In his career, his OPS+ is 96, so he’s been 4% below average in his career as a hitter, including his breakout year in 2025, when he was named an All-Star after hitting 16 home runs with a .800 OPS and a 121 OPS+.
But after a down year last year in the first season of his five-year, $57.5 million extension, there is a reason why the Royals wanted to move off Garcia’s money, as they know he’s not going to be worth it now or in the future.
There is a reason the Royals wanted to move off Garcia’s money, as they know he’s not going to be worth it now or in the future.
Somehow, they were able to find a sucker in Mariners president of baseball operations Jerry Dipoto to not only take on the rest of Garcia’s money, but also give up a trio of pitchers in return.
It’s a great trade by the Royals, and a bad one by the Mariners.
More must-reads:
+
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!