Should the Mets move this starter to the bullpen?

Given Holmes's inconsistency and New York's pressing need to improve its starting rotation amidst a crowded pool of options, the best solution to maintain his value and productivity might be to move him back into a familiar role.

Moving Holmes back to the bullpen makes sense

The Mets are in desperate need of starting pitching stability after their rotation collapsed in the second half of 2025. As of right now, New York's rotation has more questions than answers, and several starters carry uncertainty heading into 2026.

Not only are there already too many pitchers fighting for limited rotation spots, but the club's pursuit of a frontline starter this offseason will further complicate Holmes's place in the mix. Nolan McLean certainly looks like a future ace for the Mets, but the rotation as a whole is not capable of competing with the league's elite.

Given that New York is expected to be aggressive in the starting pitcher market, both in free agency and via trade, it makes sense from a depth-chart viewpoint to shift Holmes to the bullpen. On top of that, he's the only starter on the roster with proven success and experience as a reliever.

Speaking of the bullpen, the Mets also face questions in that area this offseason. With Edwin Díaz potentially hitting free agency, and Ryan Helsley, Gregory Soto, and Tyler Rogers all being unrestricted free agents, bullpen depth is quietly becoming a concern.

If New York goes all-in on acquiring a frontline starter, or on major financial commitments like re-signing one of or both Pete Alonso and Diáz, the Mets may need to address relief depth internally. Moving Holmes back to the bullpen would help alleviate part of that issue, providing a versatile and experienced arm capable of handling high-leverage innings, or even stepping into the closer's role if Díaz departs.