
Ryan Jeffers is clearly the top catcher available in the free agent market. His defensive reviews are mixed but he’s passable behind the plate. His right-handed bat is a clear asset. Over the past four years, he has a .254/.342/.440 line in 1,632 plate appearances. That translates to a wRC+ of 119, indicating he was 19% better than the league average hitter in that span. Considering that catchers are usually about 10 to 12% below par, it makes Jeffers’ bat even more valuable in context.
A good comp for Jeffers is Willson Contreras, who hit the open market four years ago. Contreras was also a bat-first catcher. The offensive production was remarkably similar. In his four years prior to free agency, Contreras slashed .249/.349/.467 for a 122 wRC+. Contreras secured a five-year, $87.5MM deal from the Cardinals.
Jeffers will likely come in a bit under that. The two players had a similar four-year run before free agency but Contreras had been hitting at that level for seven years, winning a World Series and making multiple All-Star appearances in the process. MLBTR predicted Jeffers to secure a four-year deal worth $75MM, an average annual value of $18.75MM. He received a $23.15MM qualifying offer from the Twins but is reportedly going to reject that.
The simplest fit for Jeffers would be a club that needs a catcher, but his bat is strong enough to play elsewhere. Since he isn’t an amazing defender behind the plate, he could follow a similar trajectory to Contreras, who was eventually moved to first base. Contreras has been a serviceable defender at first while continuing to be an above-average hitter.
In theory, a club that already has a decent catcher could still sign Jeffers just for the offensive upgrade, then use him as a backup catcher, part-time first baseman and/or part-time designated hitter. Jeffers doesn’t have any first base experience at the big league level. Contreras did play some first with the Cubs but it was approximately 50 innings from 2016 to 2019 and then none from 2020 to 2024.
As we do with the top free agents every offseason, we’ll run through each team’s chances of making a run at Jeffers.
All payroll figures cited are from the MLBTR Payroll Tracker, courtesy of contributor Ethan Hullihen.
Known/Likely Suitors (listed alphabetically)
Phillies: Philadelphia already has a big commitment behind the plate. They re-signed J.T. Realmuto to a three-year, $45MM deal in January. Unfortunately, that deal quickly turned sour. He hit .205/.283/.331 this year. Among players with at least 450 plate appearances, only Nasim Nuñez, Ezequiel Tovar and Matt McLain had a lower wRC+ than Realmuto’s 68. Realmuto’s defensive metrics also faded. He will turn 36 in March.
President of baseball operations Dave Dombrowski already said that the Phils will be reducing Realmuto’s workload next year. Backup Rafael Marchán hit .099/.137/.165 this year and isn’t a great option to pick up the slack. They don’t have an amazing prospect ready to jump in.
Acquiring an external catcher is distinctly possible. Going for Jeffers would be a bit complicated since the Phils have Kyle Schwarber at designated hitter and Bryce Harper at first base. Dombrowski has said that Harper could play the outfield occasionally and he hopes for Schwarber to play first base a bit more often going forward. In theory, there’s a way to spread around the at-bats, especially if the club is willing to really scale back Realmuto’s playing time.
It wouldn’t be the most efficient use of resources, especially since the club is probably going to remake the entire outfield. But they clearly have to do something behind the plate and Jeffers is the best free agent available. Next year’s projected payroll is about $30MM below this year’s spending. That’s not a ton of room by MLB standards but owner John Middleton has often been willing to keep pushing spending north.
Subscribe to keep reading and unlock all Front Office benefits.
$34.99 / year
BEST VALUEJust $2.92/month
Annually
$3.99 / month
Billed monthly
Monthly
UNLOCK FRONT OFFICE UNLOCK FRONT OFFICE100% Money-Back Guarantee
Explore All Front Office Benefits
Unlimited access to subscriber-only articles from our expert MLB writers.
Enjoy faster, distraction-free browsing across MLB Trade Rumors, Hoops Rumors, Pro Football Rumors, Pro Hockey Rumors, and the Trade Rumors app.
Explore our industry-leading MLB Payroll Tracker, Contract Tracker, Agency Database, and GM Tracker, with exclusive data and insights.
Ask our MLB experts your burning hot stove questions in live chats.
More must-reads:
+
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!