x
The Mike Trout conversation that nobody wants to have
Los Angeles Angels center fielder Mike Trout. Jayne Kamin-Oncea-Imagn Images

The Mike Trout conversation that nobody wants to have

When it comes to Mike Trout, it is an easy conversation to frame everything as either a comeback or a decline.

What is much easier to accept, though harder to say aloud, is simply this: We are further along this road than we are near the start.

That does not mean he is finished. Not at all. Trout can still control a game with one swing of the bat. He can still haul in a drive off the wall with such apparent ease you do not recognize how few others can get there at all. Those things are still there.

They are just no longer a guarantee.

Greatness in Trout has been an expectation for so long it was taken for granted. When he hits a homer, you are still impressed, yet in an anticipatory way. This happens when someone raises the ceiling on a sport.

Sadly, this version ruined us all.

Now when you get glimpses, it is not merely about appreciation. It is about deconstruction, an attempt to quantify and analyze. It is about trying to understand, instead of just enjoying.

Unfortunately, that is just how we are wired now.

We are no longer in 2014, 2016 or 2019 when Trout won his AL MVP awards and recorded triple-digit RBI. Power cannot remain infinite. In 2022, he played 119 games and hit 40 home runs. Last year, he played in 130 games and hit 26. The decline in power is inevitable and, unfortunately, Father Time does not concede to anyone. The change in power is usually not a dramatic turning point but a slow bleed.

One year, the ball does not fly quite as far. The next, recovery seems that much longer. Even the highlight plays are less frequent, even if they still exist.

This is the space where Mike Trout resides.

Mike Trout is still a premier player

Trout is still great. He is still the face of the Los Angeles Angels franchise. He is just in a different era where every extraordinary moment he offers carries a heavier significance than we may recognize.

When the ball departs his bat in a hurry and rockets toward the cheap seats, it should not spur debates of sustainability.

It should be celebrated.

When he races back and scales the wall to grab a fly ball, it should not provoke a comparison of his current range to that of 2019.

It should be savored.

Because these are the moments, previously taken for granted, that disappear first.

We shouldn't take Mike Trout for granted

It is easier to keep alive the illusion that some athletes do not age, or to cling to their history for comparative context. We crave control; we seek to define something to anticipate it.

However, careers must advance; there is no going backward. Trout, for all his persistent excellence, is no longer the 21-year-old version of himself. He is someone new, someone still incredible, but someone whom it requires a modicum more attention to fully grasp.

This truth does not diminish him in any way. It should, if anything, enhance the present moment.

Because there will come a time when swings do not clear the fences the way they have before. The wall will represent the conclusion of a drive, not the confirmation of his athleticism.

People will speak only in past tense of his brilliance, watching grainy clips and regretting that they failed to pay closer attention while it was actively happening. This is, and always has been, the arc of any legend.

So perhaps the conversation we need to have is the one no one actually wants to. Stop wishing Mike Trout were someone he used to be. Watch who Mike Trout is.

For this Mike Trout still embodies all the power that shifts games, the intelligence that directs them and the magic that ignites crowds, yet the moments in which these elements culminate no longer are guaranteed.

Which is precisely what makes them more precious than ever.

Chris Pownall

Chris Pownall is a Contributor to Yardbarker covering all major sports, including the NFL, NBA, MLB, college athletics, and the biggest storylines shaping the sports world. His work focuses on timely analysis, strong opinion, and the narratives fans are actually talking about. He also serves as an NFL Analyst for Last Word on Sports, where he provides in depth coverage and league wide perspective on the NFL

More must-reads:

Customize Your Newsletter

Yardbarker +

Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!