Photo by Vincent Carchietta-IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

The 'MLB multi-time MVPs' quiz

Created on September 8, 2026 | Total tries: 25 | Average Score: 25.0 out of 34 (73%) | Quiz FAQ

The last time Aaron Judge played a game for the New York Yankees, the Knicks were still waiting to learn who they’d be facing in the NBA Finals.

The Knicks have since been crowned champions, and the Yankees' hopes at doing the same just got much better. The three-time MVP has finally been activated for their Tuesday game against the Colorado Rockies after an 84-game absence.

The Yankees went 45-39 without Judge and currently find themselves four-games behind the Tampa Bay Rays in the American League East, with a four-game series between the two at Yankee Stadium looming in the final week of the season. Coming off of his fourth 50-homer season, third MVP award and first-career batting title, Judge was hitting .248 with 17 dingers and 38 RBI in 59 games before his rib injury.

Which brings us to today’s quiz. Judge is one of 34 players in MLB history to be named Most Valuable Player multiple times. How many of those players can you name in five minutes?

Good luck!

Did you like this quiz? Are there any quizzes you’d like to see us make in the future? Let us know your thoughts at quizzes@yardbarker.com, and make sure to subscribe to our Quiz of the Day Newsletter for daily quizzes sent right to your email!

Quiz Clue: MVPs / Team(s) with which player won MVP / Primary position(s) | Created on September 8, 2026 | Total tries: 25 | Average Score: 25.0 out of 34 (73%) | Quiz FAQ

SCORE:
0/34

TIME:
5:00

7 / SF (5), PIT (2) / OF

4 / LAA (2), LAD / P/DH

3 / NYY / C

3 / BRK / C

3 / NYY / OF

3 / PHA (2), BOS / 1B

3 / NYY / OF

3 / STL / 1B/OF

3 / STL / 1B

3 / NYY (2), TEX / SS/3B

3 / PHI / 3B

3 / LAA / OF

2 / CHC / SS

2 / CIN / C

2 / DET / 3B

2 / PHA, DET / C

2 / NYY / 1B

2 / TEX / OF

2 / DET / 1B/OF

2 / WAS, PHI / OF

2 / STL, CHC / 2B

2 / NYG / SP

2 / WSN / SP

3 / NYY / OF

2 / NYY / OF

2 / NYG/SFG / OF

2 / CIN / 2B

2 / ATL / OF

2 / DET / SP

2 / BAL / SS

2 / CIN, BAL / OF

2 / CHW / 1B

2 / BOS / OF

2 / MIL / SS/OF

Tommy Fradenburg is a freelance writer and an alumni of UNC Chapel Hill currently based in Charlotte, North Carolina. He religiously follows his favorite teams The New York Yankees and Dallas Cowboys (yes, he knows) as well as his alma mater the Tar Heels and West Ham United F.C. in the Premier League. See more of his work on Twitter @tommyfradenburg.

More must-reads: