
The Kansas City Royals‘ quest for starting pitching cost them a player they viewed as a franchise cornerstone a couple of years ago.
Wednesday, the Royals swung a deal with the Seattle Mariners for right-hander Bryce Miller plus two more arms. The cost? Headlined by third baseman Maikel Garcia. The 2025 American League All-Start slashed .268/.334/.381 in 2026. That was good for a 99 wRC+ and 1.8 fWAR.
Last year was a major step back from his breakout 2025, where he posted a 120 wRC+ and 5.6 fWAR, but still more than solid play across 82 games at age 26.
Miller was once a prize in the Mariners organization, but hasn’t been much more than flashes overall, aside from his 2.94 ERA across 180.1 innings back in 2024. Getting him, along with Logan Evans and José A. Ferrer is hardly nothing, but the optics of moving off Garcia looks cheap on the Royals’ part.
Garcia signed an extension ahead of his first year of arbitration eligibility, totaling $57.5 million across five years, with a club option for $21 million in 2031.
The 2027 campaign will be year two of that deal, where he’s slated to make $7.26 million in cash (though his AAV if $11.5 million for luxury tax purposes). For a team that hasn’t been in the top 15 in tax payroll this decade, trading Garcia is just a shocking way to plug a hole on the roster.
Maikel Garcia for Bryce Miller Trade Breakdown pic.twitter.com/HtumhrS15z
— Just Baseball (@JustBB_Media) November 18, 2026
There are certainly components of this deal to like for Kansas City, and those will be examined. But the fact remains the Royals cut costs and addressed a need with upside, but also created a hole in their lineup.
Miller isn’t a bad pitcher by any means, but he’s dealt with injuries and inconsistent play the past two years. He was very good in 2024, ranking eighth among qualified starters in earned run average. He was also 21st in innings pitched that year. But over the past two years, he was outside the top 100 in ERA among arms with at least 200 innings.
The strikeouts climbed back to 2024 rates in 2026, and the walks found the middle between 2024 and 2025. But he still posted a 4.17 ERA in 22 appearances.
Ferrer spent one year in Seattle and is an elite groundball artist, but his strikeouts dipped, his walks got worse, and his ERA stayed above four. Evans missed 2026 with an elbow injury but made 16 MLB appearances in 2025 to the tune of a 4.32 ERA.
It’s clear the prize is Miller. He’s a good arm with upside, which puts the Royals in a fascinating position with their rotation.
| Royals Projected 2027 Rotation |
|---|
| RHP Michael Wacha |
| RHP Bryce Miller |
| LHP Noah Cameron |
| RHP Seth Lugo |
| RHP Randy Dobnak |
Southpaw Cole Ragans had elbow surgery in July, leaving his 2027 in jeopardy. His presence elevates the Royals rotation. But there are still a couple arms with upside in this rotation, plus the uber-consistent Wacha at the top. Time will tell if Dobnak’s 2026 season holds up going forward, but the rotation’s overall performance hinges on the veteran Lugo.
Miller was very good in 2024 but has seen his ERA jump a run each year since. If he’s able to right the ship, he really lengthens that rotation. If he continues to slide, that could sink the Royals in 2027.
Garcia isn’t a star-caliber bat, even if you believe his 2025 season is more his true talent level. Ultimately, a 120 wRC+ is good, certainly of being in the top third of the lineup. But at third base, he needs to continue his elite defensive play to maintain a high WAR.
However, the Royals still are tasked with replacing him even if he’s closer to an average bat. RosterResource on FanGraphs projects his replacement today as Nick Loftin. Loftin posted a 98 wRC+ a year ago with six outs above average. But historically, he’s never been more than a platoon hitter at the MLB level. He posted a 90 wRC+ against right-handers in 2026, but the three years prior it was just 62.
The 28-year-old is also a career utilityman. While he played 75 games at third last year as Garcia dealt with injuries, he still played an additional 43 across several other positions.
In the RosterResource projected lineup, only outfielder Jac Caglianone had a wRC+ over 120 in 2026. Bobby Witt Jr. has a career 127 wRC+, and young catcher Carter Jensen posted a 116 in his rookie campaign, but there’s not a lot of offensive firepower in Kansas City’s lineup.
Garcia isn’t a star hitter, but he’s a commodity that must be replaced. Figure they are also projected to start a rookie in center field this year, and this feels like moving the Band-Aid off one cut onto another.
Bryce Miller for Maikel Garcia!
— Just Baseball (@JustBB_Media) November 18, 2026
Mariners and Royals make a BIG trade! @Lyle_Goldstein joins Aram and Peter to break it all down pic.twitter.com/72OVId4yRu
Loftin is the pick right now, and it honestly might be their best option barring an unforeseen trade. The Royals don’t exactly have the farm system to land a star player, nor the young assets on the MLB roster to offset the low-ranking farm system. That is, unless they wanted to trade Caglianone or Jensen, but that wouldn’t make sense given the timeline Kansas City is on.
Bohm is one of the more fascinating free agents out there. Historically, his overall value leaves a lot to be desired. However, he’s been a proverbial lock for at least 15 homers and 80 runs batted in since 2023, save for the 11 and 59 he had across 120 games in 2025.
Defensively, he’s generally ranked toward the bottom of the league. Last year, he posted -10 defensive runs saved and -8 outs above average at third base.
Between being a career 100 wRC+ hitter with historically bad defense, Bohm would be a slight improvement for the floor of the offense whilst nuking the defense. Especially since he will likely earn roughly what Garcia was owed in 2027.
Crawford is a career shortstop but played 254.1 innings at third base in 2026. It was his first run at third since he was a Philadelphia Phillie in 2018.
Crawford was a neutral defender at third, with zeroes apiece in DRS and OAA. He also comes with a bit of offensive pedigree, but only has one season with a wRC+ above 115, and that was in 2023.
As a one-year, prove-it concept, signing Crawford could be beneficial to Kansas City. However, his market value of $9-14 million means the Royals would be signing an older player to a richer deal on an average annual basis and merely hoping he’s healthier and more productive than Garcia.
As far as cheap options go, Rosario is about as top-of-the-line as the Royals can get at third base. But, like Bohm, he’s historically a weak defender. And, like Loftin, he’s historically a platoon bat coming off his first productive year against right-handed pitchers.
The Royals could certainly treat replacing Garcia as an opportunity to platoon the position, but that creates a need for an additional bat, while also still missing the mark defensively.
It’s not hard to see the appeal of Miller. He’s a talented arm with flashes of brilliance at the MLB level. However, the Royals cut corners and neglected the free agent market to add a starter while creating a hole in an already weak lineup.
Garcia isn’t making enough money to call it a clear-cut salary dump, but it’s hard to see the justification behind trading a homegrown player on a team-friendly extension. Especially at just 26 years old.
There are plenty of available starters this winter, both steady contributors and buy-low candidates. Many of these arms are not going to break the bank this winter either. Instead, the Royals marginally improved their rotation and depth, got a solid middle reliever and worsened their lineup.
The offseason is still young, and Kansas City can still get busy in replacing Garcia and improving the rotation further. But the fact remains they created more steps for themselves this winter, with time running out on Salvador Perez’s career and Witt only a few years away from a potential opt-out.
This screams of a reset from an organization that won just 69 games a year ago. But the reset would make sense if it involved moving off of veterans and letting young guys play. Trading Garcia, as it stands, opens playing time for an older utilityman to get playing time at third base. It makes the rotation younger, but until Ragans comes back, it’s still deeply flawed.
Time will tell on what the Royals do from here. But as it stands, this looks like an effort to cut some salary whilst potentially worsening their chances at improving in 2027.
More must-reads:
+
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!