x
Top Landing Spots for Free Agent Daulton Varsho
IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

The 2025 season was not the AL pennant defense that the Toronto Blue Jays envisioned. From coming inches away from winning their first World Series since going back-to-back in 1992 and 1993 to finishing in last place in the AL East, Blue Jays fans could not have expected such a fall from grace.

For veteran outfielder Daulton Varsho, 2025 was relatively positive. Despite missing two months due to a hamstring injury, Varsho had his best offensive season, recording a career-high 123 wRC+. Coupled with his 95th-percentile 9 OAA, Varsho was one of the factors that helped Toronto make it to the World Series.

As the Blue Jays looked to run things back in 2026, Varsho struggled mightily. The lefty recorded an xwOBA, xBA, xSLG, and average exit velocity below the 20th percentile across the league despite playing in 140 games.

At the trade deadline, Varsho was traded to the Houston Astros as the team looked to bolster its roster for a postseason push. However, the change of scenery did not do Varsho any favors, as the 30-year-old slashed .172/.244/.311 across 41 games. While the Astros made the playoffs at 81-81, the team was swept by the Chicago White Sox in the Wild Card Round, capping off a disappointing season for the outfielder and the ‘Stros.

Going into 2027, Varsho is back on the market, looking for a new home and a reset that can optimize his bat while letting him show off his strong defense.

Free Agent Profile: Daulton Varsho

  • Age in 2027: 30
  • 2026 Stats: 140 G, .221/.281/.355, 12 HR, 40 RBI, 78 wRC+, 0.8 fWAR
  • 2026 Salary: $10.75 million

Contract Projection

  • Contract Length Expectation: 1-2 years
  • Expected AAV: $10-15 million

Coming off a near World Series win in 2025, a down year in 2026 was a harsh return to Earth for the veteran outfielder. While Varsho looks to recapture his offensive production heading into next season, his fantastic ability in the field should be enough to land him a contract similar to the one predicted above.

Free Agent Landing Spots for Daulton Varsho

New York Yankees

For back-to-back years, the New York Yankees eliminated the Boston Red Sox in the Wild Card Round and proceeded to get bounced by another AL East team. You could say that both series were equally humiliating, as the Yankees appeared to be outmatched by divisional foes.

With Trent Grisham heading to free agency, the Pinstripes are left with a hole in their outfield. The veteran lefty made 119 starts in center field in 2026 and 328 starts across his three years in the Bronx.

While internal options like Spencer Jones and Jasson Domínguez may seem to be next in line, the team may not trust that they can cover the amount of ground needed to play center field at Yankee Stadium. Also, Jones may be a better option in right field to help keep Aaron Judge healthy after he missed lots of time this season.

Varsho has proven that he is an excellent defensive player. His 7 OAA in 2026 ranked in the 92nd percentile, a stat that will be crucial if he wants to defend well at Yankee Stadium.

It’s also important to point out that Varsho favors pulling the ball. In his career, the 30-year-old pulls the ball 44.9% of the time. Had Varsho played all of his games at Yankee Stadium, with the short porch in right field, his home run total would have jumped from 12 to 19. Across his career, the lefty is a .244 hitter with 6 RBIs and 8 runs in 21 games at Yankee Stadium.

If all things go as planned, this partnership could provide benefits for both sides. The Yankees get a great fielder in center field, while Varsho gets to hit in one of the more hitter-friendly parks in the league.

Cincinnati Reds

Another option that may help with Varsho’s offensive production is joining the Cincinnati Reds and Great American Ball Park.

With a 75-87 record, the Reds finished in last place in what turned out to be a very competitive NL Central. While being in a division with the eventual World Series winners and the Chicago Cubs may make getting to the postseason more difficult, the expectations for the young core in Cincinnati are to be playing meaningful October baseball.

Adding Varsho to the team would provide a situation similar to the one in the Bronx: a hitter-friendly ballpark that should help maximize Varsho’s bat while adding a plus defender to an outfield in desperate need of one.

Let’s start with the offensive side of things. According to Baseball Savant, Varsho would’ve recorded 18 home runs at Great American Ball Park last year, tied for the second-most in any stadium. In a lineup with few reliable lefty bats, an improved Varsho could strengthen the lineup’s versatility and production.

In the field, the Reds have had to maintain a bit of a balancing act with their current staff. JJ Bleday and Dane Myers were mainstays in the outfield for Cincinnati, playing 133 and 117 games, respectively, in 2026. The duo also both recorded a wRC+ slightly above league average.

However, Bleday and Myers were not the most adept in the field. Both players had Fielding Run Values below league average, an unfavorable mark in a stadium that favors hitters.

Adding Varsho to that outfield would help take some pressure off Myers and Bleday. If the Reds were to plug Varsho into center field, that would move Myers over to left field, a position that may better utilize his 97th-percentile arm strength. This would bolster the outfield’s defensive production beyond just Varsho’s improved fielding ability.

Cleveland Guardians

After yet another deep postseason run that ended before the World Series, the Cleveland Guardians are once again faced with an offseason where they must figure out how to get over that final hurdle.

With two-time AL Manager of the Year Stephen Vogt at the helm, the Guardians have been consistently knocking on that door. Unfortunately for the team and its fans, the door has yet to swing open.

In the outfield, new Silver Slugger Chase DeLauter and Angel Martínez both had solid seasons in the corner outfield spots. However, with Steven Kwan hitting free agency, a potential Daulton Varsho-sized hole may be open in center field.

Now, it is important to remember that the Guardians traded for former Angels outfielder Jo Adell at the 2026 trade deadline. Adell, who is under contract through 2027, was a solid bat for the Guardians, recording 32 RBIs and a 108 wRC+ in just 48 games.

However, when it comes to defense, Adell managed a -9 Fielding Run Value, good enough for the ninth percentile in baseball. That’s not exactly the number you would expect someone who robbed three home runs in one game to record.

Varsho could lock down center field, allowing DeLauter and Martínez to continue to grow while letting Adell focus on his best tool.

Los Angeles Angels

Following yet another last-place finish in the AL West, the Angels are in need of much more talent than Daulton Varsho alone can provide. Add in the uncertainty surrounding who will own the team in 2027, and Anaheim becomes one of the least favorable free-agent destinations across the league.

The main reason why Varsho could make sense in the City of Angels is his ability to move Mike Trout out of center field.

Trout’s 2026 season was the 35-year-old’s healthiest since 2018 and the first time since 2019 that he managed back-to-back years with over 100 games played.

For the Angels to have even the slightest chance of making the playoffs in 2027, Trout has to be on the field. Adding Varsho would put a great defender in center field, allowing Trout to move to one of the less physically demanding corner outfield spots or DH.

Toronto Blue Jays

Despite moving Varsho to the Houston Astros at the trade deadline, a reunion in Toronto is not completely off the table.

Varsho had been with the Blue Jays since 2023, driving in 200 RBIs, hitting 65 home runs, and winning a Gold Glove in 2024. The numbers may not have been gaudy, but he was a solid contributor for several years up north.

Ross Atkins and the Blue Jays front office have been very active over the past few years. The team has been unafraid to commit large amounts of money around its young core in an effort to go after a World Series title.

If the Blue Jays bring back Varsho, they have a pretty clear picture of what kind of player they are getting. Plugging him into center field allows the aggressive front office to go after other big names knowing they have a solid player holding it down out there.

With a team that has lots of talent on paper, running it back is not completely outside the realm of possibility.

This article first appeared on Just Baseball and was syndicated with permission.

More must-reads:

Customize Your Newsletter

Yardbarker +

Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!