
The roller coaster of a career that Jack Flaherty has had through 10 seasons makes him a difficult free agent to predict. Once the future ace of the St. Louis Cardinals, Flaherty finished fourth in Cy Young voting in 2019. He then struggled through injuries early in his career before returning in 2023, getting traded, landing in the Orioles’ bullpen, and having to sign a one-year prove-it deal with Detroit in 2024.
An arm that always had fantastic swing-and-miss stuff but struggled to locate it consistently, Flaherty was a risk the Tigers took that paid off. Eighteen starts with a 2.95 ERA and 3.12 FIP, along with just a 1.60 BB/9 and an 11.22 K/9, made him a hot commodity at the 2024 trade deadline, when he was traded to the Dodgers.
After the 2024 season, he hit free agency and oddly didn’t have much of a market, eventually settling on a return to the Tigers on a one-year deal with a player option for less money than many had predicted. His 2025 season was fine, with a 4.64 ERA and 3.85 FIP, but he was inconsistent and nowhere near the level of his 2024 stint in Detroit, leading him to pick up his player option.
Although this isn’t a history of Flaherty’s career, I tell you all of this to paint a picture of who he really is: inconsistent, unpredictable, talented, and sometimes injured. That’s exactly what we saw last season.
Flaherty struggled to get through three or four innings at times due to high pitch counts and an inability to locate the zone. The few outs he did record would often come via strikeouts. While I think he was better than his ERA showed, there are definitely concerns with Flaherty as a free agent.
It’s fair to say that you’re not getting the pitcher we saw in 2024. What you are getting is a veteran who will still produce a 27% whiff rate and a 25%+ strikeout rate, with a nasty curveball and a good fastball to pair with it. You’ll see outings where he goes six innings with three hits and a handful of strikeouts, followed by an outing where you think a DFA is possible.
His inconsistencies will keep him from landing a long-term deal, while his strikeout upside will still get him a decent chunk of change and an opportunity to be a backend starter on a true contender or a No. 2 or 3 on a middling team. Which is exactly why he should have plenty of suitors.
In my opinion, Flaherty might be the most talented arm in this bucket of pitchers. He’s good enough for mediocre teams to convince themselves that he can lead their rotation, but also good enough for contenders to give him a shot. He’s not so bad that a contender wouldn’t be interested, nor will he have to settle for a cheap team offering less money than he’s worth.
I don’t view Flaherty as the type of talent who will automatically get a multi-year deal, so he’s back on the one-year prove-it route.
The Cincinnati Reds are stuck in a position where their roster makes sense if they want to compete, but it also has a number of holes, including in the rotation. Chase Burns is the clear ace of this team with Hunter Greene out for the 2027 season. Andrew Abbott and Nick Lodolo are sufficient rotation options, but both come with red flags. Losing Brady Singer to free agency will certainly create a need for innings to be filled.
I can’t imagine the Reds feel too good about Rhett Lowder, Brandon Williamson, and Chase Petty filling two of their rotation spots. They need another veteran they can bring in to help stabilize their rotation, and Flaherty’s strikeout upside is something they could use. Would Flaherty be interested in going to Cincinnati? I wouldn’t say it’s his first choice, but his market could push him in that direction.
Cincinnati has handed out these roughly $16 million AAV contracts several times over the past few seasons. There’s a clear need and enough money to make it happen. The Reds feel like the type of team that will convince themselves Flaherty can help push them over the edge.
How much confidence do you have in the Padres’ rotation? Joe Musgrove coming back from injury comes with concerns, and Randy Vasquez, although a fine pitcher, arguably cannot be your number two. The Padres have tried the cheap, one-year veteran options in the past, and going with a slightly better one-year option is certainly possible.
San Diego cannot afford to roll out the rotation it currently has. We aren’t quite sure how new ownership will impact the offseason, but even if they have their eyes on a bigger prize, they could still use an arm like Flaherty. He’s from California and was excited about moving back west when he joined the Dodgers, so I think he’d be interested in the Padres.
For Flaherty, he gets to join a contender. For San Diego, they get a veteran arm who improves their rotation without having to commit long term, as they might with some of the more impactful options.
Let me be clear: I would much rather have the Braves go after a better arm than Flaherty, but they haven’t shown the willingness to do so recently. The Tyler Mahle trade at last year’s deadline caught a lot of flak, but it turned out to be a good move. However, he, too, is a free agent. If Atlanta decides not to target Mahle, Flaherty could be the one-year veteran they need.
Chris Sale is still one of the most dominant pitchers in baseball, and the Braves do have quality options elsewhere in the rotation. Grant Holmes has been an underrated arm, and Spencer Schwellenbach is still intriguing, although injuries have definitely pumped the brakes on his hype. Reynaldo Lopez is probably a better fit for the bullpen, making the need for another starter clear.
While I don’t think Braves fans will view this as a slam dunk, it could have a similar impact to the Mahle addition: a veteran you didn’t expect much out of but were able to get excited about in the end.
Why not the Angels? Every year, we see a non-contender sign a veteran who surprises us, only for them to hopefully trade him at the deadline, and the Angels could be that perfect match this year. Like I mentioned before, Flaherty is from California, making the Angels the most likely fit if he does settle with a non-contender.
It’s not just about him being from California. The Angels have consistently had one of the worst rotations over the past few seasons and need a veteran to help stabilize what has been a merry-go-round of underdeveloped and unfinished prospects filling innings. They have money to spend, and we know they aren’t afraid to sign veterans. The need is there, and you don’t have to squint too hard to see the reasoning, either.
Could you imagine this Diamondbacks team without Eduardo Rodriguez having a fantastic season last year? A team with a lot of talent that could see drastic changes this winter will still need a starter, no matter what direction it takes. Losing Mike Soroka is a big hit to an already weak pitching staff, and Zac Gallen’s departure, although welcomed, leaves more innings to be filled.
Obviously, getting Corbin Burnes back for a full season will be a major boost. Brandon Pfaadt even flashed at times and could at least be an option for a back-end spot, although I’m still not trusting him. Arizona’s minor league arms did not take the step forward you would have hoped, and I don’t want them to have to rely on Mitch Bratt being better.
I think the Diamondbacks will be working with a budget that doesn’t have room for a high-profile arm but does have enough money for somebody like Flaherty. If you’re going to take a one-year prove-it deal, there are much worse places to do that than Arizona.
More must-reads:
+
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!