
Sonny Gray is headed back to Minnesota. The Twins announced Wednesday that they’ve signed the free-agent righty to a two-year contract that’ll reportedly guarantee him $55MM and contains an opt-out opportunity following the 2027 season. Gray, a client of McKinnis Sports, starred for Minnesota in 2022-23 and finished second in American League Cy Young Award voting in the latter of those two seasons.
Gray’s original departure from the Twins came on the heels of a postseason run that was immediately followed by swift payroll reductions. The Twins’ 2023 payroll pushed upwards of $155MM, but as the Pohlad family explored a sale of the club, payroll was slashed by around $50MM over the next two seasons. The Pohlads eventually walked back their efforts to sell the team, instead bringing in a trio of minority investors to pay off a reported debt in excess of $400MM.
The influx of new owners was accompanied by a changing of the guard among the Pohlad family as well; Tom Pohlad ousted younger brother Joe as the team’s control person last December. Since taking the reins, the elder Pohlad brother has repeatedly gone on the record to speak about increasing payroll, investing in the club and winning back the trust of the fans. While some doubted whether that’d be the case, the reunion with Gray, the qualifying offers for Ryan Jeffers (which he accepted yesterday), and deadline trades to acquire players making notable major league salaries (i.e. Jeff Hoffman, Dean Kremer, A.J. Minter) all back up the discourse from Pohlad over the past 11 months.
Upon rejecting the Twins’ qualifying offer following the 2023 season, Gray signed a three-year, $75MM deal with the Cardinals. He played two seasons in St. Louis before being traded to Boston, as the Cardinals embarked on more of a transitional/retooling period. Gray’s lone year at Fenway was a roaring success. He tossed 169 innings with a 2.72 ERA, a 21.8% strikeout rate, a 6.7% strikeout rate and a 46% ground-ball rate. That terrific all-around performance led to a fifth-place finish in American League Cy Young Award voting — his third top-five finish in his career.
Strong as Gray’s 2026 season was, his performance came with its share of red flags. Last year’s 21.8% strikeout rate and 9.9% swinging-strike rate were his lowest marks since 2016 in Oakland. Gray’s average four-seamer dipped to a career-low 91.5 mph. His 92 mph average sinker was the second-slowest mark of his career. And while he induced chases off the plate at a career-best 32.8% clip, per Statcast, Gray also allowed contact on a career-high 92.1% of pitches within the strike zone. He’s never exactly been a flamethrowing power pitcher, but Gray increasingly looks more like the “crafty veteran” who’s reliant on location and weak contact than he does an overpowering ace.
Gray returns to the Twins as a 37-year-old veteran. While the coaching staff and much of the roster has turned over, he’ll be rejoining several familiar faces — including his top two rotation-mates. Gray, Joe Ryan and the returning Pablo López — who missed the ’26 season following UCL surgery — give the Twins an excellent top three in the rotation. They’ll be joined by 2026 breakout right-hander Taj Bradley. López might not be ready out of the gate, but his internal brace surgery took place in mid-February, so it’s possible he’s ready to go early in the year.
Competition for the fifth spot will be steep and include a host of veterans and prospects. Bailey Ober, the aforementioned Kremer, Connor Prielipp, Zebby Matthews, Mick Abel and Kendry Rojas will all be in that mix. Some of those names could wind up bullpen-bound. Matthews, who’s struggled to find consistency as a starter across parts of three seasons, and Rojas have particularly compelling cases. Former top pitching prospect David Festa, who missed the 2026 season due to thoracic outlet surgery, could find his way into the bullpen competition as well.
Even before this reunion, it felt like there was a reasonable chance the Twins would trade Ober or move on via a non-tender. He and Kremer now both stand as trade candidates, although given that the latter was only acquired this past summer, he seems to be on firmer ground. Either could command decent interest on the trade front, however, even if neither will garner a major return. Both are projected by MLBTR contributor Matt Swartz for a salary just shy of $7MM.
Bringing Gray back into the mix helps to solidify the Twins as a genuine threat to contend in 2027, but his contract structure does little to address the uncertainty beyond the upcoming season. If Gray opts out, the Twins could see him, López and Ryan all become free agents. Ober and Kremer, if they stick around, are also set to reach free agency in the 2027-28 offseason. Bradley is the only established member of the staff who can’t reach free agency one way or another next winter. That could change if Minnesota hammers out extensions for López and/or Ryan, but right now the rotation is lined up for some major turnover in one year’s time.
That’s a down-the-road concern for the team to address, however. For now, Gray deepens an already interesting rotation mix that’ll be supported by franchise center fielder Byron Buxton and collection of promising young hitters. Luke Keaschall and top prospects Walker Jenkins and Emmanuel Rodriguez will be in the outfield alongside Buxton. Gold Glove finalist Brooks Lee has third base locked down. Top prospect Kaelen Culpepper debuted at shortstop this summer and held his own, though he might eventually be pushed to second base in deference to another top-100 shortstop prospect, Marek Houston, who elevated his stock with a big 2026 showing in the minors. Kody Clemens has second base or first base handled in the interim. The Twins could look to add a bat at either position. Behind the plate, Ryan Jeffers will be back in the fold after surprising the industry by accepting the Twins’ $23.14MM qualifying offer.
Minnesota’s bullpen remains a work in progress and figures to be a point of focus. They’ll have various trade candidates to peddle as they look to bolster the relief corps, including left fielder/DH Trevor Larnach, former No. 1 pick Royce Lewis, and the previously mentioned Ober and Kremer. If the Twins want to further bolster the starting staff — or bring in a bat of particular note for the left side of the infield — they could look to dip into their stock of controllable young starters and aim for a higher-profile acquisition.
It’s unclear just how high Tom Pohlad is willing to push payroll, but it suddenly seems not only fair to assume but downright likely that the endpoint will establish a new franchise record. Earlier this week, the Twins were projected for a $124MM payroll by MLBTR contributor Ethan Hullihen. Jeffers has since accepted his qualifying offer, and the Twins promptly signed Gray. That adds upwards of $50MM to next year’s books — depending on the exact structure of Gray’s two-year contract. Even if the Twins move on from each of Ober, Kremer and Lewis, that’d leave them right in the vicinity of their all-time record — and that’s before adding a bat on the right side of the infield or doing anything to address the bullpen.
Time will tell how aggressive the club plans to be to address those remaining needs, but Pohlad deserves some credit for remaining true to his word and boosting payroll in a way that few would’ve expected from the Twins at the outset of free agency. Reuniting with Gray and Jeffers while welcoming López back from UCL surgery is a nice starting point for a Twins club was in Wild Card contention for much of the season, finished with 77 wins, and now looks newly recommitted to fielding a competitive club.
Jon Heyman of the New York Post first reported the guaranteed salary. ESPN’s Jeff Passan first reported that the deal includes an opt-out.
More must-reads:
+
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!