x
White Sox To Sign Dustin May
IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

10:07am: Agent Craig Rose confirms to Jon Heyman of the New York Post that May has agreed to a three-year, $52.5MM deal to join the ChiSox.

10:01am: The White Sox and right-hander Dustin May are in agreement on a three-year contract, reports Robert Murray of FanSided. The Paragon Sports International client will receive just north of $50MM.

It’s a surprisingly strong deal for May. The White Sox are placing a notable bet on the right-hander’s relative youth — he’ll pitch next season at 29 — and power arsenal, while looking past his lengthy injury history and middling bottom-line results when healthy in each of the past two seasons.

May played the 2026 season on a one-year, $12.5MM deal originally signed with the Cardinals, who traded him to the Brewers alongside reliever JoJo Romero at the deadline. He posted back-end results in St. Louis and was torched for a 5.65 ERA in 10 starts (36 2/3 innings) with Milwaukee before also struggling in the playoffs. May finished out the regular season with a 4.70 ERA in a career-high 145 2/3 innings (4.77 in 156 2/3 frames, including the playoffs).

Over the past two seasons, May has combined to toss 278 innings with a 4.82 ERA. He’s fanned a roughly average 22.2% of his opponents in that time with similarly average command (8.8% walk rate) and ground-ball tendencies (42%).

The 2025 and ’26 campaigns are the only two seasons in which May has pitched more than 56 major league innings in a given year. He underwent Tommy John surgery in 2021, which sidelined him late into the 2022 season. His 2023 campaign was cut short by surgery to repair a torn flexor tendon. The rehab from that injury, plus surgery to repair a frightening esophageal tear, wiped out his entire 2024 season.

May was long one of the top pitching prospects in baseball prior to his debut. Today’s three-year pact is a bet on that former pedigree and his power repertoire. He averaged 96.9 mph on his four-seamer and 96.6 mph on his sinker this year between St. Louis and Milwaukee. May also mixed in a cutter that sits 93.3 mph, a slider that sits 86 mph and a low-90s changeup.

Despite that power arsenal, May has rarely missed bats at a high level. In his 53 combined innings from 2021-22,  he fanned 29.1% of his opponents with a gaudy 13.4% swinging-strike rate. In the three seasons he’s pitched since that time, he’s fanned 21.6% of opponents with an 8.7% swinging-strike rate. Both marks, particularly the latter, are shy of average.

The White Sox’ hope is that May’s stuff can lead to another level. Four previous clubs have tried to coax that out of him with minimal success. Metrics like FIP (4.08 from 2025-26, 3.63 in ’26 specifically) and SIERA (4.22 from ’25-’26, 3.99 in ’26 alone) feel he’s outperformed his earned run average. That was also true of Jack Flaherty when he was a 29-year-old free agent with better results and durability, though Flaherty lacked May’s high-end velocity. That’s clearly a key differentiator here. Time will tell whether Chicago’s show of faith proves wise or whether this contract follows the Taijuan Walker path for surprisingly steep prices on a former top prospect who hits the market at a relatively young age.

May will now step into a rotation that also includes some combination Sean Burke, converting reliever Grant Taylor, veteran Luis Castillo, Davis Martin and Anthony Kay. Young lefty Noah Schultz and young right-handers David Sandlin and Tanner McDougal have all had at least a fleeting taste of big league experience. Righty Shane Smith was Chicago’s Opening Day starter after a big 2025 rookie showing but was optioned after three ugly starts (8 1/3 innings total) and struggled enough in Triple-A Charlotte that he didn’t get another look in 2026. Former top prospect Drew Thorpe should have a clean bill of health in his first full season back from UCL surgery, too.

As can be seen in MLBTR’s Payroll Tracker, the South Siders had a projected $108MM payroll before agreeing to terms with May. That sum includes projected arbitration raises for several key players and was already north of the paltry $98.93MM at which Chicago finished the 2026 campaign. May will push that sum north by a good margin but still nowhere close to the franchise-record $193MM payroll the ChiSox trotted out back in 2022.

General manger Chris Getz has suggested that adding starting pitching is his “top priority” this winter. May gives them an upside play to plug into the middle of the staff, but he’s not the sort of proven workhorse one might expect for a White Sox club that defied all preseason projections and expectations to reach the playoffs via a Wild Card berth in 2026.

The White Sox have an impressive and affordable collection of young bats. The lineup is largely set, with first baseman Munetaka Murakami, second baseman Chase Meidroth, shortstop Colson Montgomery, third baseman Miguel Vargas, left fielder Sam Antonacci, center fielder Tristan Peters, right fielder Braden Montgomery and catcher Kyle Teel all returning. There’s probably room to add a bat in the first base/designated hitter/right field mix — likely at the expense of playing time for Andrew Benintendi and/or Braden Montgomery — but the lineup is in good shape, broadly speaking.

The rotation, on the other hand, still features plenty of question marks — including May himself. It’d be a surprise if this were the lone starting pitching addition made by Getz & Co. this winter. Some form of certainty, thus pushing Burke/May/Martin/Taylor down the pecking order would be prudent. It might make for a crowded group, but each of Martin (who struggled immensely from June onward), Thorpe, Smith, Sandlin, McDougal and Burke (not that he’s at risk of being sent down) have minor league options remaining. Kay can’t be sent down but has experience as both a starter and reliever.

There’s no question that it’s a nice collection of depth the Sox have amassed, but it still looks to be a work in progress.

This article first appeared on MLB Trade Rumors and was syndicated with permission.

More must-reads:

Customize Your Newsletter

Yardbarker +

Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!