x
Why the Tigers Still Need Rotation Help
IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

Think back to this time last winter. Detroit had just dropped a tough seven-game series to the Seattle Mariners, where the need for starting pitching was evident. Injuries throughout the season forced the Detroit Tigers to, once again, lean into bullpen games and unique strategies to get through the year.

The front office addressed that need by signing Framber Valdez to a big contract, adding Drew Anderson, and bringing back franchise legend Justin Verlander. A weakness quickly looked like a strength, with Cy Young winner Tarik Skubal leading the way alongside Casey Mize, who was coming off a career year. Funny how much can change in such a short period of time.

Verlander pitched in just two games due to injury, and Framber Valdez wasn’t nearly what the Tigers thought he would be, while Casey Mize and Tarik Skubal were both shipped out at the deadline. If I had told you that would happen before the season, you would have thought the rotation was a complete disaster. However, it wasn’t all bad.

Troy Melton and Keider Montero not only filled important innings but also showed that they could be pieces of the rotation moving forward. Their seasons weren’t perfect, but both took massive steps forward and finished the year in what I’d call the best-case scenario for each. Jackson Jobe‘s return from injury was also promising, even if some rust was still present.

Detroit’s rotation has a lot of upside and youth, but not much predictability or stability. The lack of experience and the question marks surrounding its young arms make adding to the rotation a priority this offseason.

The Tigers’ Current Options

If there’s one thing baseball fans know, especially Tigers fans, it’s that you need more than five arms to get through a season. You can find different studies and opinions, but having around eight starters you’re comfortable with taking the ball on any given day should be sufficient to get through a season. Not all of them need to be high-level, but they do need to be major-league caliber.

Trying to replace Skubal with a similar arm will not be possible. A back-to-back Cy Young winner isn’t someone who hits the market often or becomes available via trade. I know you’re saying, “Well, he’s available right now. Go sign him.” You and I both know that’s not going to happen, so there’s no need to waste time discussing it.

Currently, the Tigers’ options are Framber Valdez, Troy Melton, Jackson Jobe, Keider Montero, River Ryan, Drew Anderson, Reese Olson, and Andrew Sears. A proven veteran who’s been a frontline starter, with plenty of talent and question marks behind him.

Let’s go ahead and slot Valdez in as the number one starter. Although his 2026 season wasn’t quite up to par, I still view Valdez as a high-level pitcher and expect him to bounce back to his old self, or at least provide the Tigers with a high floor and plenty of innings. There’s one.

Finding the number two starter is not as straightforward. We saw enough from Troy Melton and Jackson Jobe in 2026 to see a path where either could become a number two starter in 2027, but banking on that is tricky. Not only are they young pitchers without large sample sizes, but both have yet to pitch a full season due to injuries and have had their moments of concern. While I do believe both should be in the rotation, I’m not yet ready to announce either as a true number two.

And that’s okay. Having two viable options to fill that spot is a good problem to have. Both should be in the rotation, giving the Tigers three pitchers whose ability and upside I feel confident in, even if two of them don’t have the track record to make me feel 100% comfortable. Let’s go ahead and say the Tigers have three pitchers you can sharpie in.

That leaves two more spots and five more names. Again, a great problem to have. Keider Montero should be the frontrunner and likely does have a spot in the rotation. A 3.48 ERA across 155 innings and 25 starts was an impressive mark and made him an important part of the Tigers’ 2026 season. However, the Tigers have moved him back and forth from the bullpen enough times that I’m not sold on him being a lock for the rotation throughout the year. We can call it four arms to be comfortable with.

The last four names — Drew Anderson, Reese Olson, River Ryan, and Andrew Sears — are much less certain than the previous four. We’ll start with Sears. Even throughout his time in the minors, I’ve always viewed him as more of a bullpen piece. Perhaps he leans into that role this season or serves as starter depth in Toledo. I don’t think he has a chance of being the fifth starter out of the gate.

River Ryan, one of the primary returns in the Skubal trade, comes with the most upside of the group and should see his fair share of innings in 2027. Due to his injury history, I don’t think the Tigers should fully rely on him to be the fifth starter or even count on him to reach 100 innings. A similar story applies to Reese Olson. We really don’t know if he’s healthy or what to expect from him in 2027.

Olson is a pitcher I was high on, but after two straight injury-plagued seasons, I cannot comfortably expect him to return to form without seeing it first. As for Drew Anderson, I prefer him in the swingman/spot starter role he played in 2026 rather than entering the rotation as a full-time member. I’d like to see the Tigers address their bullpen more this offseason, and adding Anderson into the mix certainly makes the bullpen better.

Sure, you might say that having this many talented arms is enough for the 2027 Tigers. Most seasons, I’d probably agree with you. However, I view 2027 in a different light.

Why the Tigers Need Another Starter

How many straight seasons do the Tigers have to deal with injuries before we learn our lesson and stop settling for what they have? Look across the league, and you’ll quickly understand that pitcher injuries happen every season to every team. Having the luxury of quality depth in the minors might be just as important as having high-end arms.

A 162-game season, followed by the playoffs, is a grind. A battle of attrition. For this exact reason, many high-profile teams continue to add to their rotation, even if it looks set on paper. Some don’t have the luxury of doing so, but I think the Tigers do.

In order to add to a rotation that’s already solid, you need two things to be true. First, there’s money to spend. Second, players have minor league options.

With Detroit losing Skubal, Mize, Torres, Flaherty, and others over the past six months, their payroll has been lightened a bit. You’re looking at over $60 million coming out of their rotation compared to Opening Day. To me, the Tigers have the money to afford a starter of the caliber that would actually be a difference-maker in this rotation.

They also have players with options. Melton has three minor league options, Montero one, Jobe three, Ryan two, Olson two, and Sears three. Of those six pitchers, only Montero has pitched over 150 innings in a season, leaving me with concerns about their ability to handle a full workload in 2027. We could see some mixing and matching, players bouncing up and down from the minors, or returns from injury delaying a full workload for any of these pitchers.

While this innings math and injury insurance make sense, we also need to consider the fact that the Tigers are going to try to be legitimate contenders in 2027. If the front office believes they have a chance to compete for a World Series, then they’ll need to add a veteran arm with more experience and a higher floor to help the Tigers get through the season.

I’d argue that this is exactly what we saw last winter. On paper, the Tigers had a good enough rotation, but they continued to add more veterans to the mix. The last thing you want to see is a good roster spoiled by a rotation without the necessary depth to stay in the race all summer long. Would adding another starter be a luxury? Of course, but it’s one that the Tigers can and should pursue.

Final Thoughts

We already know that Detroit has an interest in Shota Imanaga, and I’m sure other arms are on their radar. Not only do they have the money to add a free agent, but they also have a good enough prospect pool to pull off a trade if they’d rather go that route. There’s a need, evidence from last winter that this path is possible, and an expectation to win that all lead me to believe another starter will be added.

Don’t get cute. You don’t have to prove you’re the smartest guy in the room or that you can win on the margins. Add a veteran, beef up the rotation, and make sure the 2027 season makes us all forget about 2026.

This article first appeared on Just Baseball and was syndicated with permission.

More must-reads:

Customize Your Newsletter

Yardbarker +

Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!