Bill Simmons Claims The Lakers Will Not Win A Title If LeBron James Takes $50 Million Contract

Simmons raises some valid points by bringing up LeBron's win-loss record while active over the last two seasons and his relatively ineffective net rating. James is amidst a healthy season, averaging 25.3 points, 7.1 rebounds, and 8.0 assists this season. Even Anthony Davis has been healthy and more available than James, averaging 24.8 points, 12.5 rebounds, and 2.5 blocks.

Davis has a three-year, $186 million extension kicking in at the end of the 2024-25 season.

Even with the performances of their two stars, the Lakers are stuck in the battle for the No. 6 seed, currently stuck at No. 9. This could be their third Play-In appearance with LeBron and AD, indicating that the team really isn't built for sustainable success. If James re-signs on a max, the team is likely stuck with their current roster unless they make trades that sacrifice depth for star power.

Lakers Future Salary Looks Occupied

The Lakers managed to create free cap space this summer after trading Russell Westbrook away for expiring contracts like D'Angelo Russell, Rui Hachimura, and Malik Beasley. Russell and Hachimura have already been re-signed, while Austin Reaves also received a big-money extension. The three would combined for over $48.5 million next season, provided D'Lo accepts his $18 million player option. If he doesn't, the Lakers likely will have to re-sign him as they don't have the space to replace his outgoing salary.

Jarred Vanderbilt also secured an extension this season, earning $10.1 million next season. If LeBron theoretically accepted his $51.4 million player option along with AD making $43.3 million, the Lakers would be over the $141 million salary cap with just these six players.

Additional salaries like Gabe Vincent, Jalen Hood-Schifino, Max Christie, Taurean Prince, and more rotational players will likely take them close to being a second apron team, which restricts future draft picks, trades, and free agent acqusitions. 

The Lakers could aggregate some of their mid-range rotational salaries for a third player and hope they can find value on the minimum market to bolster their rotation. Players like Trae Young and Donovan Mitchell have been linked, but they'll be challenging deals for an asset-strapped Lakers to pull off. 

If LeBron was to re-sign on a discount and take just $25 million or lesser, the team has a lot more room to navigate roster building with James slotting in as the third-highest paid player if another star is acquired. That's more manageable and would be a fantastic value contract.

If LeBron was to take a discount to contend for another title. people would mock him. If he doesn't, people will call him greedy. Even though his play would get any player a max contract in the NBA, James will be scrutinized for the decision given his age. If the Lakers don't offer what he wants, they lose arguably the biggest commercial asset in the NBA right now. LeBron has the bargaining chip of wanting to play with his son as well, so the Lakers have a huge offseason ahead.