Boston Celtics’ Offseason Crisis Begins with Jayson Tatum’s Injury

Tatum was in the midst of one of the greatest playoff performances of his career, stuffing the stat sheet in every category as he put the Celtics on his back, hoping to even the series.

Then, disaster struck.

Tatum’s ankle gave out while chasing a loose ball, sending him crashing to the court. His immediate, frantic call for a timeout as he writhed in pain painted a devastating picture. 

For a player who has been one of the NBA’s most durable stars, it was a scene Celtics fans hoped they would never witness.

As fans await updates on Tatum’s recovery timeline, questions are flooding the minds of Celtics fans about the future. 

Is this the end of this iteration of the Celtics? What does this mean for a team facing a daunting financial outlook?

Changes Are Inevitable

Whispers of the Celtics potentially shaking up their roster began weeks ago.

ESPN’s Shams Charania and Brian Windhorst both reported on the Celtics’ looming $500 million luxury-tax bill and the new CBA restrictions as concerns for the team’s ability to retain its star-studded lineup.

If the Celtics had repeated as champions, perhaps ownership would have been willing to endure the financial strain. But with a second-round exit now likely, and the complication of Tatum’s injury, the chances of that happening are slim.

Financial Pressure Mounts

The Celtics have five players — Jayson Tatum, Jaylen Brown, Jrue Holiday, Kristaps Porzingis, and Derrick White — each set to earn over $28 million next season, totaling more than $198 million in salary.

Factor in their other guaranteed contracts, and the team’s payroll is projected to exceed $227 million.

That’s well above the NBA’s projected salary cap of $154.6 million and the luxury tax threshold of $187.9 million, according to ESPN’s Bobby Marks.

Worse yet, Boston is on track to exceed the second apron, which is 134.4% of the salary cap— roughly $207 million given the current projections.

Surpassing the second apron brings severe penalties, including restrictions on trades, free-agent signings, and even draft capital usage.

Though they could apply for a Disabled Player Exception to offset part of Tatum’s salary, it would only provide a $14.1 million exception.

While that may help, it is far from a solution to their larger financial issues.

The Need for Change

The Celtics’ aging core and mounting salary concerns leave little room for patience. If Tatum misses the entire 2025-26 season, it’s unrealistic to expect this current roster to compete for a title two years from now.

They cannot afford to simply wait for Tatum to return.

Boston must begin reshaping the roster now, aiming for flexibility without completely abandoning contention.

Who Could Be on the Move?

The only truly untouchable player on the Celtics is Jayson Tatum. Beyond him, everything is on the table.

Jaylen Brown is the most likely to stay. As the longest-tenured Celtic and the 2024 Finals MVP, he is more than just the team’s co-star— he’s a foundational piece. His $236 million extension further solidifies his status as a cornerstone of the franchise. Trading Brown would be a seismic shift, one that ownership is unlikely to gamble on, especially in just their second year in control. Breaking up the Tatum-Brown duo would mean the end of an era, and that’s not a decision they seem eager to make.

Derrick White has solidified himself as the ultimate role player. His ability to defend multiple positions, knock down shots, and adapt to various roles makes him invaluable, especially at $91 million over the next three seasons. For a team facing a financial crunch, White’s versatility and relatively affordable contract provide stability in uncertain times.

Kristaps Porzingis and Jrue Holiday are the most logical trade candidates. Acquired just last season, both played pivotal roles in the Celtics’ championship run. But their hefty contracts, combined with their age, make them expendable. The challenge will be finding a market for them. Porzingis’ injury history and Holiday’s offensive decline may dampen interest, but their reputations as proven veterans could still attract contenders.

Dark horse trade candidates include Payton Pritchard and Sam Hauser. Both are on team-friendly deals, which makes them appealing trade assets for teams seeking affordable depth. Ideally, the Celtics would like to keep them, but their low-cost contracts also make them the easiest to move if a deal needs to be made.

The Road Ahead

The Celtics have no easy way out of this financial conundrum, but the silver lining is that they have a plethora of talent to work with as they determine the vision of their next championship team.

The Celtics must balance flexibility with competitiveness, navigating tough financial waters while retaining enough talent to remain in the title conversation. In a wide-open Eastern Conference, Jaylen Brown and a retooled roster could still keep them in the hunt.

One thing is certain: the coming years will require tough decisions. General manager Brad Stevens will have his hands full.