Trevor Ruszkowski-Imagn Images

Gonzaga Alum Andrew Nembhard Delivers Game-Winner and Defensive Stop in Pacers OT Thriller

Originally posted on Athlon Sports | By Blayne Gilmer | Last updated May 22, 2025 9:54 AM ET

In a moment that Gonzaga fans won't soon forget, Andrew Nembhard delivered two game-winning plays in overtime to seal a dramatic 138-135 victory for the Indiana Pacers over the New York Knicks in Game 1 of the Eastern Conference Finals. The former Bulldog standout showcased his trademark basketball IQ and demonstrated the grit and defensive toughness that the Gonzaga faithful came to love during his time in Spokane.

Nembhard finished the game with 15 points and four assists, and hit a huge three to pull the Pacers within one point with just under three minutes remaining, but it was his poise and execution in the game's final seconds that stole the spotlight. With the Pacers trailing 135-134 and the shot clock winding down, the Knicks' defense collapsed on Tyrese Haliburton at the top of the key. Recognizing the over-help, Nembhard slipped behind the defense on a perfectly timed backdoor cut. Haliburton delivered the pass in stride, and Nembhard laid it in off the glass with just 16 seconds remaining, giving Indiana the 136-135 lead.

Andrew Nembhard buries a massive triple in overtime. pic.twitter.com/gFPmQpvyfX
— Indiana Pacers (@Pacers) May 22, 2025

But Nembhard wasn't done. With the game on the line, Pacers head coach Rick Carlisle trusted the second-year guard to take on the Knicks' star Jalen Brunson on the final defensive possession. Nembhard answered the call, staying glued to Brunson with physical defense, forcing him into a deep, off-balance three-pointer that missed badly as time expired.

The moment was a testament to Nembhard's development and composure on the biggest stage of his young NBA career. Gonzaga fans have long known of his elite decision-making and calm under pressure, but watching him deliver under the bright lights of Madison Square Garden was a proud moment for the Zags community.

From Spokane to Indianapolis, Nembhard's steady hand and cerebral approach to the game continue to earn him respect. His performance in Game 1 was a masterclass in awareness, toughness, and clutch execution, qualities forged during his time at Gonzaga.

For Zags fans, seeing Nembhard take over a playoff game on both ends of the floor isn't just exciting—it's deeply gratifying. He's carrying forward the legacy of Gonzaga guards who perform and thrive when it matters most.

This article first appeared on Athlon Sports and was syndicated with permission.

More must-reads: