After the Los Angeles Lakers pulled off a historic heist to acquire Luka Dončić at the trade deadline, the expectations were sky-high.
But despite the glitz and glamour of the blockbuster move, year one ended in disappointment.
The Lakers were upset in the first round of the playoffs by the Minnesota Timberwolves, suffering the franchise’s first-ever opening-round exit as a No. 3 seed or higher since 1981.
Given that L.A. constructed a drastically different roster midseason, growing pains were to be expected. But what few anticipated was how starkly Dončić’s long-standing flaws with defense and conditioning would resurface, and perhaps grow worse, on the game’s biggest stage.
Dončić’s lack of engagement on the defensive end was glaring.
He routinely struggled to stay in front of ball handlers and offered little resistance on switches or closeouts.
Just as problematic was his late-game conditioning. As games wore on, his energy dwindled, and so did his ability to offset defensive lapses with offensive brilliance.
The issue isn’t his talent. Dončić remains one of the most gifted offensive engines the game has ever seen. However, his lack of sustained effort and focus on defense has become a storyline that refuses to go away.
Expectations for Dončić have always been different because he’s been different since day one.
He averaged 21.2 points, 7.8 rebounds, and 6.0 assists as a rookie, cruising to the Rookie of the Year Award with 98 out of 100 first-place votes.
He followed that up with five consecutive All-NBA First Team selections, as he joined Tim Duncan as the only two players in league history to earn that honor by their second season.
His 2023–24 campaign was arguably his most dominant yet. He averaged 33.9 points per game, which ranked 19th all-time for a single season in NBA history and third-highest in the 21st century.
Meanwhile, his scoring wizardry is matched by his elite playmaking. His uncanny vision and ability to deliver precision passes out of double teams earned him the nickname “Luka Magic.”
His passing is so elite that in the 2024 NBA Finals, the Boston Celtics opted to guard him one-on-one despite his efficient 29.2 points per game simply to avoid the havoc his passing could cause.
He is, without question, one of the most complete offensive threats the game has ever seen.
But even during that Finals run with Dallas, Dončić’s defensive issues couldn’t be ignored.
The Mavericks built a scheme that funneled ball handlers into their interior defense, using length and rim protection to mask Dončić’s poor lateral quickness.
Here's another example of the Mavs funnel defense:
Mavs force Jaylen left, into help. Luka helps and the Mavs get into rotations.
Celtics end up with a contested Hauser 3. Luka Doncic for the 3rd time in the first quarter played solid help defense to ultimately force a miss.… pic.twitter.com/2iGZTqIgdn
— NBA Film (@NBAFilmSessions) June 11, 2024
It worked— to a degree. Dallas was ninth in the league in blocks after the All-Star break and fifth among playoff teams.
But that didn’t stop the Celtics from going at him, and having success doing so.
As laid out by an epic rant from ESPN’s Brian Windhorst, he simply wasn’t good enough on that side of the floor.
Good lord, Brian Windhorst just unloaded the clip on Luka Doncic pic.twitter.com/nA4TOMLfNA
— Ahmed/The Ears/IG: BigBizTheGod
(@big_business_) June 13, 2024
The Mavericks’ defensive gameplan was simply a Band-Aid over a deeper problem.
And with the Lakers, who traded away Anthony Davis and lacked rim protection, Dončić’s defensive flaws were no longer covered up. They were exposed. Repeatedly.
This isn’t a new issue.
Dončić’s conditioning has long been a talking point. During the 2021–22 season, reports emerged that he entered training camp weighing over 260 pounds. And while injuries have played a role in his fitness, the larger question is his commitment to solving the issue— considering it’s still a conversation years later.
After Dallas’ exit from the 2022 Western Conference Finals, Dončić publicly admitted that his defense had to improve.
ESPN’s Tim MacMahon reported his comments following the series:
“I think defense has got to be way better for me… Honestly, I think I made a huge step this year defensively, but there’s so much room for improvement. I’ve got to be way better there. I think that’s one spot that can take us to the next level.”
Yet again, years later, it is still a discussion, as that “next level” has yet to be seen.
Dončić is just 26 years old. He still has time— and he’s already built a foundation worthy of the Hall of Fame. He’s one of only 28 players in league history with five All-NBA First Team selections.
But greatness comes with expectations.
The whispers around his conditioning and defensive indifference didn’t just grow louder. They contributed to the Mavericks’ decision to move on from their franchise cornerstone.
“I believe that defense wins championships,” Mavs GM Nico Harrison told ESPN regarding his motivation to trade Luka Doncic for Anthony Davis. “I believe that getting an All-Defensive center and an All-NBA player with a defensive mindset gives us a better chance. We’re built to… https://t.co/iPfQvA4str
— Tim MacMahon (@espn_macmahon) February 2, 2025
Mavs owner Patrick Dumont on Luka Doncic:
“If you look at the greats in the league, the people you and I grew up with — Jordan, Bird, Kobe, Shaq — they worked really hard, everyday with a singular focus to win. And if you don’t have that, it doesn’t work… You shouldn’t be… pic.twitter.com/3HXVY3qhg5
— NBA Film (@NBAFilmSessions) February 9, 2025
Now, with another playoff exit surrounded by intensifying scrutiny, Dončić enters the most critical offseason of his career.
If he doesn’t commit to reshaping his body and sharpening his defensive focus now, when will he?
These are his prime athletic years, and he’s yet to fully maximize them. Father Time is undefeated, and history doesn’t look kindly on squandered potential.
This offseason isn’t just about redemption. It’s about defining who Luka Dončić will ultimately be.
A generational talent who rose to meet greatness?
Or one who settled for brilliance without ever reaching his ceiling?
More must-reads:
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!