The Indiana Pacers have struggled to contain Cleveland Cavaliers star Donovan Mitchell in the series, and it may cost them if he continues to light up their defense.
Mitchell is one of the league's best scorers, seemingly able to create his own shot at will by breaking down switches or using his dribbling skills to generate space.
The Pacers have struggled to manage Mitchell's explosiveness, finding it difficult to defend against the pick-and-roll, as their guards cannot stay in front of the All-Star guard.
Donovan Mitchell in series vs. Pacers:
— Underdog NBA (@UnderdogNBA) May 10, 2025
43 PTS
48 PTS
33 PTS
First player since KD in 2019 to drop 43+ in back-to-back playoff games.pic.twitter.com/yXJHyNm541
In the first three games of the series, Donovan Mitchell has scored 33, 48, and 43 points, effectively shouldering the offensive load despite injuries to the Cavaliers' starters.
There will be a game or two when Mitchell is feeling it from the 3-point line, and he could carry the Cavs to a win himself if the defense does not try to disrupt his rhythm.
So far in the series, Mitchell has not shot well from three, but that will likely change quickly, meaning the Pacers need to get the ball out of his hands at all costs.
More Pacers News: NBA Announces Big Update to Pacers-Cavaliers Playoff Series
Evan Mobley, Darius Garland, and DeAndre Hunter missed the first two games of the series due to injuries, placing a considerable burden on Mitchell to generate offense.
In Game 2, his 48-point performance was almost enough for the Cavs to win; however, late-game execution issues and a clutch performance from Tyrese Haliburton ultimately cost Cleveland the victory.
More Pacers News: Pacers' Pascal Siakam All But Guarantees Game 4 Win For Indiana
It was no surprise that once the Cavs' injured list shrank, they won their first game of the season, as Mitchell no longer had to shoulder such an intense load, and he had Garland to set him up on offense.
DONOVAN MITCHELL OMG!!!!! pic.twitter.com/kmPfXgVG9e
— Bleacher Report (@BleacherReport) May 7, 2025
Moving forward, head coach Rick Carlisle must make adjustments to contain Mitchell, ensuring he cannot get started and placing the onus on the other players to make the difference.
When Myles Turner is defending Mitchell one-on-one, there should be a plan to avoid that match-up.
Andrew Nembhard or Ben Sheppard must cover him on the ball.
At the same time, potential double teams can be initiated from players on the wing, such as Jarace Walker or Bennedict Mathurin, who are agile and possess the length to challenge Mitchell effectively.
There can also be more coordinated double teams from the Pacers, forcing the ball out of Mitchell's hands and rotating around the court.
No matter what adjustment Carlisle decides to make, the team will need to show intensity and commitment to stopping Mitchell, or the momentum of the series could shift back to Cleveland.
More Indiana Pacers News:Pacers Have Massive Advantage in Postseason They Didn't Have Last Year
For more news and notes on the Indiana Pacers, head on over to Indiana Pacers
More must-reads:
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!