When Tyrese Haliburton stepped to the free throw line in the second quarter of Game 2 of the Indiana Pacers' second-round playoff series against the Cleveland Cavaliers on Tuesday, fans at Rocket Arena showered him with "overrated" chants, referring to the guard recently being voted the most overrated player in the league by his peers in a poll by The Athletic.
Cavs star Donovan Mitchell, who scored a game-high 48 points in Game 2, didn't care for the taunting and motioned for the crowd to cease chanting.
By the end of the game, though, it was clear that the Olympic gold medalist Haliburton was unfazed by the noise and belongs among the NBA elite.
Down by three points with 27 seconds left, Indiana intercepted Cleveland's inbound pass. Haliburton attacked the rim and was fouled, sending him to the free-throw line.
He made the first, missed the second, but corralled the offensive rebound. The Pacers guard proceeded to splash a go-ahead, crowd-silencing step-back three-pointer with 1.1 seconds left. Cleveland's desperate half-court prayer wasn't answered, capping the Pacers' comeback victory.
TYRESE HALIBURTON WINS GAME 2 FOR THE PACERS
— NBA (@NBA) May 7, 2025
WHAT. A. WILD. PLAY. pic.twitter.com/rFsjZmtrBz
"There was no chance I was passing [the ball] down the line. This is what I do, and I just tried to make a big play," Haliburton told TNT Sports.
Indiana trailed by as many as 20 points in Game 2 and by seven with 48 seconds left. But, when it mattered most, Haliburton delivered for his team in the clutch, a recurring theme this postseason.
Tyrese Haliburton of the @Pacers is the only NBA player in the last 20 years to rebound his own free-throw miss and then hit the game-winning 3-pointer, all in the last 15 seconds of a game (regular season or playoffs). pic.twitter.com/YN1e3jSWjz
— OptaSTATS (@OptaSTATS) May 7, 2025
Since 1997-98, playoff teams trailing by at least seven points in the final minute of the fourth quarter or overtime have won only three of 1,643 games, per ESPN. Remarkably, the Pacers account for two of those victories in their last three contests.
"We just have a resilient group, man," said Haliburton, who finished with 19 points and four assists. "We just figure out ways to win. We don't give up. We're battle-tested as a group. We've basically been together for about two years now and that continuity has been really good for us."
After splashing the game-winning shot, Haliburton broke out Sam Cassell’s banned “Big Balls” celebration—the kind that earns you a hefty fine from the league but a standing ovation from teammates and fans alike.
TYRESE HALIBURTON HIT THE SAM CASSELL CELEBRATION AFTER HIS GAME WINNER
— Legion Hoops (@LegionHoops) May 7, 2025
ICE COLD
pic.twitter.com/GTdr6RxmiE
“I’ve been waiting for that, man,” Haliburton said postgame. “It was just right in the moment. I’ll take that fine gladly.”
While the "overrated" label will likely follow Haliburton until the next poll, it has already lost validity. Under the bright lights of the NBA playoffs, the 6-foot-5 guard has repeatedly prevailed over his superstar peers.
During the Round 1 matchup against the Milwaukee Bucks, Haliburton averaged a double-double and in Game 5, sprinted by former DPOY Giannis Antetokounmpo for the series-clinching basket in overtime.
Through two games against Cleveland, the Iowa State product continued to thrive in clutch situations.
According to The Volume's Carson Breber, Haliburton is now 10-of-11 on shots to tie or take the lead in the last two minutes this season.
Tyrese Haliburton is 10-11 on shots to tie or take the lead in the last two minutes this year.
— Carson Breber (@Carsobi) May 7, 2025
That clutch gene is showing up in these playoffs. He's stolen two of the most improbable wins we've seen with takeover scoring late.
Now, after leaping out to a 2-0 series lead, Haliburton and the Pacers head back to Indiana in search of a series sweep.
More must-reads:
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!