A season removed from their deepest playoff run since the early 1990s, the Washington Commanders' age and lack of depth are finally beginning to catch up with them.
Despite missing Jayden Daniels, Terry McLaurin, Noah Brown, and John Bates, the Commanders' offense still found enough to hang around against the Atlanta Falcons. However, the problems ran deep defensively.
Although Adam Peters brought in several veterans in the offseason to plug and play, the cracks are already beginning to show. With injuries to Jonathan Jones, Deatrich Wise Jr., and Will Harris, coupled with veterans like Von Miller and Marshon Lattimore offering little impact, the defense looked a step slow against an Atlanta Falcons team coming off an embarrassing shutout loss to the lowly Carolina Panthers.
The final scoreboard may have looked close, but the performance on the field didn't. Against a better opponent, this had the chance to become an NFC Championship game-esque blowout for Washington.
With a match-up with the Los Angeles Chargers up next, the Commanders need to get right in a hurry. However, as the New York Giants proved, the NFL really is an 'Any Given Sunday' type of league.
Here are the five key metrics that defined Washington's Week 4 loss to the Falcons, dropping them to 2-2.
12: The big play counter is back once again. The same issues that plagued this defense under Jack Del Rio have resurfaced under Joe Whitt Jr. The Commanders' defense was gashed over and over, giving up 12 big plays (passes over 15+ years and runs over 10+ yards).
The Commanders’ defense surrendered chunk plays all afternoon, giving up passes of 15 (twice), 17, 19, 22, 26, 43, and 69 yards, plus runs of 11, 15, and 19. One of the lowlights came on Bijan Robinson’s 14-yard touchdown, where he slipped through three would-be tacklers, just a fraction of the 12 missed tackles Washington piled up on Sunday.
Bijan dances it into the end zone!
— Atlanta Falcons (@AtlantaFalcons) September 28, 2025
CBS | NFL+ pic.twitter.com/K8omVL2kk3
50: Coming into the game, Washington had the best third-down defense in the NFL, allowing opponents to convert only 28.57 percent of the time. It flipped quickly, with the Falcons converting on 6-of-12 (50%) of their attempts. To make matters worse, Atlanta gained 26 yards on a 3rd-and-5, 17 yards on a 3rd-and-2, and 22 yards on a 3rd-and-6.
9: On the flip side, Washington's offense didn't help itself either. The Commanders went just 1-for-8 on third downs, with an average of 9 yards to go. Already ranked 21st in the league in third-down conversions, the team's struggles on early downs were magnified without Daniels, who often masks many of the team's deficiencies.
66.67: Atlanta had just seven red zone trips all season entering Week 4, scoring touchdowns on only 28.57% of them. Against Washington, the Falcons had six visits, resulting in four touchdowns for a 66.67% success rate.
6.68: The Commanders wasted another strong performance on the ground, despite the team averaging 6.68 yards per carry. Chris Rodriguez Jr. broke out for a 48-yard run, and Jacory Croskey-Merritt added a 16-yard run of his own. The problem? Kliff Kingsbury waited too long to lean on the running game, with only eight carries the entire first half.
Chris Rodriguez Jr. rips off a 49-yard run for the @Commanders
— NFL (@NFL) September 28, 2025
WASvsATL on CBS/Paramount+https://t.co/HkKw7uXnxV pic.twitter.com/z875X7V00w
Despite the challenges, there were a few bright spots, including Luke McCaffrey's second receiving touchdown , Matt Gay connecting on all four of his field goals, and Mike Sainristil snagging the defense's first takeaway of the year.
At 2-2, the Commanders still have time to get right for the season, and that starts with getting a win in Los Angeles next week. This team overcame a three-game losing run last year en route to the NFC Championship game. They must find a way to overcome the early adversity to do it again this year.
More must-reads:
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!