The Tampa Bay Vipers block a kickoff against the New York Guardians during the first quarter of an XFL football game at MetLife Stadium. Brad Penner-USA TODAY Sports

NFL might turn to XFL for rule change

The XFL's kickoff rule might get a promotion.

The NFL is considering adopting the spring football league's kickoff rule, which most greatly differs from the NFL's rule in that players are prohibited from moving until the ball is caught by the returner. Players on the kicking team also start at the opposing 35-yard line instead of their own 35-yard line. 

The NFL adjusted its kickoff rule this offseason. On a one-year trial basis, a fair catch by returners will bring the ball out to the 25-yard line. NFL Network's Tom Pelissero reported coaches were "unanimously" against the rule change.

Browns special teams coordinator Bubba Ventrone confirmed that report and went even further. "All coordinators were against it, the players are against it, but supposedly there's data," he said.

The league has used player safety as an excuse to slowly take kickoffs out of the game. Patriots special teams ace Matthew Slater called the NFL's motives for the rule change into question.

"I just don't believe this is truly in the name of player health and safety," Slater said. 

San Francisco's special teams coach, Brian Schneider, shared that sentiment, saying the rule could have the opposite effect in terms of injuries. "I think there could be more returns, there could be shorter kicks, there could be more collisions."

With the play under scrutiny, some think it's only a matter of time before the league gets rid of kickoffs entirely. That would have a devastating impact on several players, including Slater.

He noted, "For a player like myself, I wouldn't have had a career most likely [without] this play... I [also] understand the players that came before me ... the [Steve] Taskers, the [Bill] Bateses ... who were able to have long careers ... because of the kicking game."

While its temporary change looks destined to be a failure, the NFL may have better luck graduating the XFL's rule, even if it means admitting the struggling league came up with a better kickoff alternative than its brightest minds could concoct.

Kickoffs will probably look a lot different in the near future. But that's better than not having them at all.

More must-reads:

TODAY'S BEST
Stars center matches Gretzky feat as Dallas pushes Avalanche to brink
Gritty young Thunder take down veteran Mavericks in Game 4
Cubs acquiring veteran reliever from Mariners
Top-five NBA Draft prospect suffers scary non-contact injury
Hurricanes stay alive with third-period outburst vs. Rangers
Jaylen Brown's big three-pointer gives Celtics 3-1 lead over Cavs
Avalanche star placed in player assistance program
Mercury announce devastating injury on eve of WNBA season
Randy Moss' son makes major football announcement
Reds place key outfielder on injured list with broken thumb
Tom Brady's broadcasting debut set for Week 1 of NFL season
Struggling Cubs reliever placed on injured list 
Report: Justin Fields had ‘toxic' relationship with ex-Bears QB
Extension makes Lions QB Jared Goff one of NFL's highest-paid players
Kentucky's Reed Sheppard displays excellent skills at NBA Draft Combine
Knicks big man undergoes another ankle surgery
Flames CEO stepping down, transitioning to advisory role
Oilers star seemingly dismisses Arturs Silovs' performance in Game 3
Bengals QB Joe Burrow is making a notable change to stay healthy in 2024
Orioles designate outfielder for assignment

Want more NFL news?

Join the hundreds of thousands of fans who start their day with Yardbarker's Morning Bark, the best newsletter in sports.